Men At Arms | Litsy

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

so-so

This one was a bit of a murder mystery with themes of racism and gun violence/control, as well as classism. Once again, I found the commentary to still be relevant and interesting; it was bold to have MCs representing that prejudice and racism, but that also made them a bit less likable, although very human. There were other off-color comments and actions I didn't really like, but they are a product of their time.

2 likes

julesG

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

#OokBOokClub-ers, our Discworld adventure continues TODAY with #TheatreOfCruelty (in A Blink of the Screen) and #MenAtArms!

Looking forward to our discussion next month!

Happy reading!

#Discworld #SirTerryPratchett #TerryPratchett #PratchettPosse #ReadAlong #BuddyRead #EpicBuddyRead

julesG @dariazeoli @Soubhiville @GingerAntics @rubyslippersreads @Karkar @kwmg40 @Liatrek @khooliha @TheSpineView @BookmarkTavern @Jennifer3 @Fortifiedbybooks @willaful @SconsinBookyBadger @Balibee146 @Deblovestoread @TheAromaofBooks @Chrissyreadit @Lizpixie @BarbaraJean @alamich

1w

36 likes1 comment

LitsyEvents

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

repost for @julesG:

#OokBOokClub

Just a reminder that we'll be reading #MenAtArms AND #TheatreOfCruelty (in Blink of the Screen) next! Dig out your books, put in your library holds, or place your orders! The next Discworld adventure continues on June 8th!

If anyone wants to be tagged/untagged for future posts please let me know! Happy to oblige!

#Discworld #SirTerryPratchett #TerryPratchett #PratchettPosse #ReadAlong #BuddyRead #EpicBuddyRead

julesG Thanks!!! 1mo

32 likes1 comment

julesG

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

#OokBOokClub

Just a friendly reminder that we'll be reading #MenAtArms AND #TheatreOfCruelty (in Blink of the Screen) next! Dig out your books, put in your library holds, or place your orders! The next Discworld adventure continues on June 8th! Woohoo!

If anyone wants to be tagged/untagged for future posts please let me know! Happy to oblige!

#Discworld #SirTerryPratchett #TerryPratchett #PratchettPosse #ReadAlong #BuddyRead #EpicBuddyRead

44 likes1 stack add1 comment

Robotswithpersonality

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

This post contains spoilers

show me

pick

Always a wonderful time to reread a City Watch book in the Discworld series. I admit that this probably ranked lower in my last reread because I was focused on thinking of the City Watch books as the Vimes books. Sam Vimes has a dark night of the soul here and the ending establishes a key post for the character going forward, as well as the running joke of his unwilling promotion, but he actually doesn't participate in much of the plot or action.

Robotswithpersonality 2/? This is a book where the Watch starts to take shape, where Carrot's previously suggested royal lineage is most addressed, where he and Angua start to figure things out, where the multi-species makeup of the watch is established as a very effective commentary on police forces often being the unthinking or righteously complicit tool of systemic racism. Of course gun violence is the loud point of commentary in the narrative, but 8mo

Robotswithpersonality 3/? while Pratchett manages to convey an effective and chillingly sinister lesson about the necessity of gun control, or preferably, the non-existence of guns, it felt like the discussions of racism/speciesm hit harder because the ignorant views initially come from the Watchmen's mouths themselves, even Carrot's. The 'gonne' is an adversary, an outside threat, possibly with supernatural powers, but prejudice is insidious 8mo

Robotswithpersonality 4/4 because your friends and coworkers might be saying it without thinking, i.e. hurting a potential love interest with unexamined thought from the mouth of a man professed to be universally likeable. Harder, and more important to shed a light on. Well done, Terry.
⚠️animal death 8mo

1 like3 comments

Robotswithpersonality

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

pick

Discworld City Watch books reread continues! I was right to remember this one as an ensemble piece. As with Guards, Guards, upon reread my biggest gripe is that Sam Vimes is still figuring himself out, and we don't get as much of him on the page as I prefer. 😏 It's a lot less confusing getting a chronological intro to Detritus and Angua this time round! 1/2

Robotswithpersonality 2/2 While the gun control commentary remains chillingly effective, what really struck me this time 'round was how skillful, concise a replication is shown of the kind of casually racist scripts common in the 20th century, unexamined prejudice thinly veiled via troll/dwarf hate. Found family/'gang's all here' vibes of the watch do not prevent the author from making pointed references to corruption, brutality, injustice, prejudice that are often associated with police forces (and politicians). 2y

Robotswithpersonality P.S. Gaspode is a smelly treasure. 2y

5 likes1 stack add2 comments

Robotswithpersonality

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

Stay human. ♥️

7 likes1 stack add

MariaW

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

School started after the summer break and I am back to my daily commute. I went back to Terry Pratchett. I really like the Nightwatch novels and I love Captain, ahh Commander Vimes. And the wry comments of Vetinari and lovely naivety of Carrot and … I just love everything. 💗💗💗

53 likes

SolaRaynor

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

“Cats will amusingly tolerate humans only until someone comes up with a tin opener that can be operated with a paw.“ --Terry Pratchett, “Men at Arms“.

RaeLovesToRead Pickles also uses me as a hot water bottle! 😸 4y

SolaRaynor @RaeLovesToRead Aaww! Love it :) 4y

johncadams @SolaRaynor What a sweetie! 4y

SolaRaynor @johncadams He is...most of the time! 4y

34 likes4 comments

TK-421

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

“Dwarfs were not a naturally religious species, but in a world where pit props could crack without warning and pockets of fire damp could suddenly explode they'd seen the need for gods as the sort of #supernatural equivalent of a hard hat. Besides, when you hit your thumb with an eight-pound hammer it's nice to be able to blaspheme.” #QuotsySep21

40 likes

TobeyTheScavengerMonk

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

I made it through 2 Discworld books during my career-change imposed Litsy hiatus, & my completionist spirit mandates that I add reviews of them to my #DiscRead thread.

Book 15 deals with the chaotic introduction of a fire arm into the fantasy of the Discworld, & the efforts of the Ankh-Morpork City Watch (newly diversified with a troll, a dwarf, & a werewolf in the ranks) to stop a killer.*

The subject matter made this the darkest entry so far.

TobeyTheScavengerMonk *Plus a very special appearance by Gaspode the Wonder Dog! 5y

MariaW #gnuterrypratchett #speakhisname I love Gaspode! 😍 5y

44 likes2 comments

Mangelli

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

So fun and immersive just like the rest of his Discworld series!

2 likes

TK-421

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

“No clowns were #funny. That was the whole purpose of a clown. People laughed at clowns, but only out of nervousness. The point of clowns was that, after watching them, anything else that happened seemed enjoyable.” #QuotsyMar20

Crazeedi This is true! 5y

51 likes1 comment

KatjeIsWriting

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Not pictured: the ebook I'm reading on the Libby app.

This is the pile of books I brought up to my mom's place in January when I thought I'd be visiting my husband every month (and thus able to grab more books as needed).

Now there's a pandemic and I'm quarantined with strange symptoms awaiting the results of my swab.

Thankfully there are ebooks and mom's personal library of over 10,000 books. I'll be okay.

Lindy It sounds like you are back at work since posting this? (edited) 5y

KatjeIsWriting @Lindy yes! My swab came back negative for covid or flu, so I'm back on the roster for work. Conclusion is my allergies are worse in this town and that's what caused the burning sensation in my lungs. 5y

Lindy @OfMonstrousWords Hope medication is enough to control your allergy symptoms, and without impairing your daily activities. Stay strong! 🌻 5y

6 likes3 comments

Andrew65

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

#QuotsyFeb20 #Copper

TK-421

Geenie Interesting 5y

68 likes1 comment

Riveted_Reader_Melissa

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

I‘ve gotten a bit behind with my #PratchettPosse
#OokBOokClub reading, but this week the library came through with this one & the next 2...so Catch-up weekend!

I really enjoyed this one, I think the Watch is my second favorite group, I love reading about them. And I loved seeing my favorite librarian & dog make appearances again too.

As always Practchett spins a delightful yarn, with lots of wit and wisdom buried in there if you pay attention.

DrexEdit I am grooving on The Watch as well. Really enjoyed this book! 😊 5y

JazzFeathers I read the first book in The Watch bunch a few years ago and really enjoyed it. I need to get more of them. 5y

KCofKaysville I liked it a lot too. Not sure when I read it.
4y

61 likes3 comments

Riveted_Reader_Melissa

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Sometimes the big crimes are so big and far-reaching they are almost impossibly to see at a glance.

#PratchettPosse
#OokBOokClub

50 likes

Riveted_Reader_Melissa

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

#PratchettPosse
#OokBOokClub

43 likes

Riveted_Reader_Melissa

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

#PratchettPosse
#OokBOokClub

charl08 Genius! 5y

DrexEdit 💜😂😂😂 5y

JazzFeathers 😂😂😂😂😂 Oh my goodness! Help! 😂😂😂😂😂😂 5y

43 likes3 comments

Riveted_Reader_Melissa

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

#PratchettPosse
#OokBOokClub

36 likes

gossamerchild

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Oh, the Librarian 🤣🤣🤣 I think he is probably my favorite character. I think I've said that before 🤔🙄😏

I'm a little behind on the #OokBOokClub reading, but I'll catch up at some point.

#pratchettposse

26 likes1 stack add

khooliha

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

This post contains spoilers

show me

I am listening to Radio Morpork and one of the hosts is describing one of the romances in it as a D/s relationship and he's talking about Carrot and Angua and NOT Vimes and Sybil??? I am puzzledly, tilting my head so far that it's in danger of falling off.
#OokBOokClub

khooliha I wouldn't take Gaspode's word on human relationships, is the real takeaway. 5y

julesG There is absolutely no emoji that could convey what I looked like reading your blurb twice! Say whaaa?! 5y

khooliha @julesG I think he put too much stock in Gaspode saying "He's your master." Again, don't put stock in Gaspode! 5y

3 likes3 comments

julesG

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

pick

The Guard is growing on me. They will never crawl into that special place in my heart held by the Witches, but they might get the second row seats. 😉

#OokBOokClub #Discworld #SirTerryPratchett #TerryPratchett #PratchettPosse #ReadAlong #BuddyRead #EpicBuddyRead

Lucy_Anywhere The City Guards are my fave Pratchett books 😊 5y

81 likes1 stack add1 comment

julesG

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

#OokBOokClub @TricksyTails

Hello friends! Open discussion is in the FOLLOWING POST marked as a spoiler. Find Men At Arms post & tap “show me“ on the spoiler tag to join in the discussion. Join in whenever you can! Today. Tomorrow. Next month! The post will always be up so just tag each other & we'll jump in to discuss with you. Feel free to chat about anything!

#Discworld #TerryPratchett #PratchettPosse #ReadAlong #BuddyRead

rubyslippersreads, Riveted_Reader_Melissa, Gezemice, Soubhiville, jpmcwisemorgan, AmyG, hgrimes, leslieseidel, Chrys, Karkar, Gdsjenny, DrexEdit, Craftylikefox, jmtrivera, gossamerchild, mklong, everlocalwest, cobwebmoth, Aimeesue, Velvetsun, khooliha, Liatrek, Larkken, Moray_Reads, Marmie7, dariazeoli, slategreyskies, TK421, SconsinBookyBadger, alisiakae, kwmg40, CindyMyLifeIsLit, laurieluna, toric, Cheshirecat913, CoffeeCatsBooks, CatLass007, Iblu, SamanthaMarie, amber_ldsmom, TheSpineView, NeedsMoreBooks

49 likes

julesG

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

This post contains spoilers

show me

#OokBOokClub @TricksyTails

Welcome to the #OokBOokClub open discussion for #MenAtArms! Feel free to discuss anything! Don't forget to tag each other in the comments so your friends can see your reply. Have fun!

#Discworld #SirTerryPratchett #TerryPratchett #PratchettPosse #ReadAlong #BuddyRead

julesG Vetenari and Carrot trying reverse psychology made me giggle. 5y

Aimeesue “Sometimes it‘s better to light a flamethrower than curse the darkness.” 😂 5y

khooliha One of my strongest memories of this book is from my first read, when I told my best friend I had cried over Cuddy's death and got mocked for it. 5y

See All 13 Comments

khooliha Anyway, I love this book! I love all of the new characters introduced and I love the new phase of life Vimes gets. 5y

Gezemice @Aimeesue This one is full of quotables. My favorite is Vimes‘ Boots theory of economic inequality. 5y

Gezemice @khooliha This was my first “real” Discworld book and I loved it so much I did not stop until I read all the Watch books. This is still my favorite. Hilarious from start to end (those letters from Carrot 😂 ), the characters are awesome, one of the best Discworld plots, and there is some serious commentary on racism, hate, sexism, prejudice... even good people like Carrot have issues with the undead. Until they get to know one. 5y

khooliha @Gezemice This would be a great starter book! It's a good showcase for character development, a promise of how (most) of the series will go. My starter was The Last Continent and I think it's -technically- a bad starter, but I love it just the same. 5y

julesG @khooliha @Gezemice I read this book for the first time. My first Pratchett was Pyramids. I agree, MaA is a good starter. I'll keep it in mind for future reference. 😉 5y

Aimeesue @Gezemice I quote Vimes' Boots Theory ALL the time! Brought my kids up to live by it, when they can. 5y

Gezemice @Aimeesue I quote it often, too, although have not brought my kids up that way lol. 5y

Gezemice @khooliha Last Continent is one you kinda have to know Discworld for already... I am glad you liked it and kept reading! 5y

Gezemice @julesG Yeah, I recommend it usually as a starter, although Guards, Guards would work as well. Personally I think Men at Arms is better because more of the characters are there and Vimes is no longer a happless drunk. 5y

khooliha @Gezemice It made middle school me laugh A Lot, and Rincewind is a type of character I have always loved. It worked out! 5y

16 likes13 comments

khooliha

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

Guards, Guards! established the Watch, but Men at Arms -makes- it. A joy to read even when it's sad.

3 likes

khooliha

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

This post contains spoilers

show me

Some stray thoughts:
- So Carrot is asexual, right? Like, not sex repulsed, but ace
- We should have dropped in on Cuddy's ghost a second time, post- funeral
- Vimes kind of falls out of the book for awhile and I wished we had cut back to him periodically.
- When the heck does this book take place wrt Guards, Guards? I need a timeline.
- Vetenari and Carrot just trying not to grin at each other with their Vimes plans is Very Cute
#OokBOokClub

2 likes

khooliha

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

This post contains spoilers

show me

This description is TERRIBLE
#OokBOokClub

2 likes

khooliha

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Also, I love Vetenari. I don't know if the series thinks I should? But I do.
#OokBOokClub

5 likes

khooliha

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

I forgot that Cuddy and Detritus bond over counting. I did not forget that I love them.
#OokBOokClub

4 likes

khooliha

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Merry Christmas to me, I'm getting to read Men at Arms!
#OokBOokClub

Gezemice Merry Christmas! 5y

6 likes1 comment

gossamerchild

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

This is another reason I love Terry Pratchett. He GETS me 🤣🤣🤣. I have a huge hangup with italics in books, so I feel seen with these sentences.

#OokBOokClub #pratchettposse

julesG 🤣🤣🤣 6y

24 likes1 comment

julesG

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

#OokBOokClub-ers, our Discworld adventure continues TODAY with #MenAtArns!

Looking forward to our discussion next month!

Happy reading!

@TricksyTails

julesG @TK421 @4thhouseontheleft @DrexEdit @laurenbescoby @CatLass007 @gossamerchild @everlocalwest @Riveted_Reader_Melissa @jpmcwisemorgan @anansigirl @Craftylikefox @Gezemice @Chrys @Cheshirecat913 @dariazeoli @Soubhiville @Velvetsun @Larkken @Iblu 6y

julesG @AmyG @jmtrivera @rubyslippersreads @leslieseidel @Karkar @kwmg40 @CindyMyLifeIsLit @Gdsjenny @Marmie7 @slategreyskies @mklong @Liatrek @Moray_Reads @cobwebmoth @khooliha @Aimeesue @hgrimes @SamanthaMarie @toric @TheSpineView @CoffeeCatsBooks 6y

Gezemice That‘s one of my favorites, I need to make sure to re-read! 5y

julesG @Gezemice 👏👏👏 5y

58 likes4 comments

julesG

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

Just a friendly reminder that next month we'll be reading #MenAtArms! Dig out your books, put in your library holds, or place your orders! The next Discworld adventure continues on December 8th! Woohoo!

If anyone wants to be tagged/untagged for future posts please let me know! Happy to oblige!

@TricksyTails

#OokBOokClub #Discworld #SirTerryPratchett #TerryPratchett #PratchettPosse #ReadAlong #BuddyRead

CoffeeCatsBooks Could you tag me as well in the future? There are a lot of Pratchett titles I haven‘t gotten to yet and I‘d love to join in. 6y

See All 7 Comments

julesG @CoffeeCatsBooks Sure! Just added you to the list. 6y

Iblu Me too please, still in!! 6y

julesG @Iblu I've added you to the list. 6y

Iblu 🤗 thank you!! 6y

64 likes7 comments

uwak

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

it was nice seeing familiar and new faces back at the Night Watch in a murder mystery 😊 although I felt parts of this book kind of dragged and Pratchett is unfortunately one of those authors who struggles writing coherent action scenes. The unexpected death of a certain character towards the end made me surprisingly sad 😭

#fantasy

5 likes

uwak

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

🐀🍅

MayJasper 😂😂😂 rat without ketchup! That way lies madness! 6y

4 likes1 stack add1 comment

uwak

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

cold and rainy weather calls for a return to the Discworld and the Night Watch (aka time to get back to the books I bought in June...) ☔

3 likes

TK-421

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

“Foul Ole Ron was a Beggars‘ Guild member in good standing. He was a Mutterer, and a good one. He would walk behind people muttering in his own private language until they gave him money not to.” #Incoherent #QuotsyJune19

Soubhiville Bugrit! Millennial Hand and Shrimp! 6y

TK-421 @Soubhiville 😂 Yes! 6y

54 likes2 comments

catsuit_mango

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

What do you do when your current book is a doorstop per that you can't carry in the public transportation? You start another book for the bus-subway ride to work. And when once at work you don't have enough to keep you busy? You start reading an eBook on your computer. That my friends is how you end up reading 3 great books at the same time ;) as the doorstopper Les furtifs. as the bus read the haunting of hill house. as the eBook men at arms ;)

BooknerdsLife Hahaa that‘s why I‘m always multiple books at a time too 😂 Each book for each different occasion 👍🏼 6y

catsuit_mango @BooknerdsLife i'm trying to avoid this now but I used to have up to 5 books on the go ;) 6y

9 likes1 stack add2 comments

Emma3

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

Didn't finish any books in March 😱😱 but this is my first one for April
Love Terry Pratchett and the Discworld series

33 likes

Soubhiville

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

“The Librarian was, of course, very much in favour of reading in general, but readers in particular got on his nerves. There was something, well, sacrilegious about the way they kept taking books off the shelves and wearing out the words by reading them.”
Terry Pratchett, Men At Arms

olivia.ferz 😂😂😂 7y

TheBogwitch Ook 7y

69 likes1 stack add2 comments

Soubhiville

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

pick

Men at Arms is one of my favorite of the Discworld books. The action kicks off right away, the story is well developed and fun, and all my favorite Watch characters are here! We get to see a bit inside the Assassins, Thieves, and Beggars Guilds, and hang out some more with Gaspode, Dibbler, and Death. A perfect book!

TheBogwitch Loved this series. I think Mort might have been my favorite. 7y

60 likes1 stack add1 comment

Soubhiville

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Froedrick and I hereby decree 📜: Today is a day dedicated entirely to reading! I‘ll be finishing up my latest Owl Post Book, (which is wonderful the second time through @Foragingfantasy ) and also Song of Achilles on audio as I have breakfast, then diving into Discworld with Men at Arms, an old favorite.

Happy Sunday everyone! 🧡

#Froedrick #CatsofLitsy #OokBOokClub #PratchettsPosse

ErickaS_Flyleafunfurled I ❤️ Froedrick!! 😻 7y

Jee_HookedOnBookz Love Song of Achilles! 7y

AmyG Happy Sunday! He is too cute. Those 👀 7y

Mimi28 Aaaawww he‘s adorable!! 😻😻 7y

LauraBeth He looks so soft! 😻 7y

92 likes5 comments

Soubhiville

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

I‘m determined to read Hogfather by Christmas this year, and so I am devoting December to Discworld. Here‘s my #DecemberTBR ! (Plus audiobooks- Lilac Girls at least, probably 1-2 others as well.)
#PratchettsPosse #DiscworldLove #OokBOokClub

Aims42 I love re-reading the Hogfather around Christmas. Death and Death of Rats are by far my favorite characters LOL 💀🐭 SQUEAK!! (edited) 7y

Booksnchill I have those editions as well- so lovely! 7y

82 likes1 stack add2 comments

Moray_Reads

Men at Arms (Revised) | Terry Pratchett

julesG 😍😁 7y

saresmoore I love this. 7y

44 likes2 comments

hoggman

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Participated in a book swap last weekend with a couple of friends. Got rid of a few classics I'd been meaning to read but hadn't gotten around to.

rather_be_reading hey check your email. i need your full address for the Hocus Pocus Swap 🎃 7y

13 likes1 comment

jillrhudy

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Reading “Men at Arms” on my Kindle Paperwhite for a book discussion with Anglophiles Anonymous on Goodreads. I love the Guards novels nearly as much as the Witches novels. #anglophilesoflitsy #discworld #ookbookclub

Aims42 Yes, same here! I can‘t pick a favorite between those two lol 7y

18 likes1 comment

Aimeesue

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Carrot! Nobby Nobbs! Detritus! Vimes!
And of course, The Patrician, Lord Vetinari, Who will always and forever be played by David Bowie in my head.
#Dogsoflitsy #AnglophilesofLitsy

19 likes

Booksbymybed

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

Discworld fix

11 likes1 stack add

jpmcwisemorgan

Men At Arms | Terry Pratchett

#comic #Quotsy #QuotsyMay18 #LitsyQuoteChallenge

TK-421

rubyslippersreads This ties in well with my coulrophobia. 🤡😱 7y

Tera66 Do not like clowns. Do love this quote! 7y

jpmcwisemorgan @rubyslippersreads Nearly every time I see anything about clowns I think of the girl in college who had a huge clown on her dorm room door and how it started a kerfluffle with someone because they thought it shouldn‘t be up because there might be people around with a coulrophobia. I don‘t remember the outcome, though. 7y

jpmcwisemorgan @Tera66 I think you‘re in good company with your dislike of clowns! 7y

49 likes4 comments

Welcome to Litsy!

Trending Hashtags

Trending Books