Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Secret Place
Secret Place | Tana French
An absolutely mesmerizing read. . . . Tana French is simply this: a truly great writer. Gillian Flynn Detective Stephen Moran has been waiting for his chance to join Dublin s Murder Squad when sixteen-year-old Holly Mackey arrives in his office with a photo of a popular boy whose body was found at a girls boarding school a year earlier. The photo had been posted at The Secret Place, the school s anonymous gossip board, and the caption says I KNOW WHO KILLED HIM. Stephen joins with Detective Antoinette Conway to reopen the case beneath the watchful eye of Holly s father, fellow detective Frank Mackey. With the clues leading back to Holly s close-knit group of friends, to their rival clique, and to the tangle of relationships that bound them all to the murdered boy, the private underworld of teenage girls turns out to be more mysterious and more dangerous than the detectives imagined."
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
andrew61
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

5th in the Dublin murder squad combined an interesting pair of Garda detectives who are outcasts in the squadroom with the claustrophobia of a girls boarding school. The teenagers are captured perfectly with their secrets , jealousies, conspiracies, and passions, a perfect setting for a murder. My only issue is that at 540 pages, it could have lost about 50 pages, but otherwise, another great read.

36 likes1 stack add
review
Bookwormjillk
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

Finally finished this one for July‘s #BacklistReadathon

I think this was one of Tana French‘s best, but as a parent to teens it freaked me out. My kids are never going to boarding school 🤣

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! We realized we kind of missed officially hosting the #BacklistReadathon for July, so I'm glad you carried on anyway 😂 We'll be back for August!! 8mo
Clwojick Great Job! 💛💛💛 I have the Likeness by this author on my shelf… have you read it? (edited) 8mo
Bookwormjillk @Clwojick yes, I‘ve liked the whole series so far. I think that‘s the 2nd but you don‘t have to read them in order. 8mo
See All 6 Comments
Bookwormjillk @TheAromaofBooks I have a whole thing written down, so I‘m in for the year now! Even if I don‘t ever finish in the official Readathon week. 8mo
Susanita This was great on audio, with two different narrators. 8mo
64 likes1 stack add6 comments
blurb
Bookwormjillk
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

It‘s been a busy week with family but I finally got some time today to sneak out and take an audio walk and read by the lake. My audio is The Secret Place by Tana French and I‘m still slogging through my book club cozy on kindle. #JubilantJuly

Andrew65 Sounds heavenly, pouring with rain here. 9mo
62 likes1 comment
blurb
LeslieO
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

I love the slow burn of a Tana French mystery. Elite girls boarding school + Murder. #SetinHighSchool #MarchMagic

TripleS Love her books!! 13mo
Eggs Great pick!! 13mo
42 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
deeannloso
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

I got through this one a bit faster because I‘ve had trouble sleeping. I‘m bummed this is the second-to-last book in the series but I‘m also excited to see how Ms. French will wind up the series. In each book, the narrator(s) has something devastating/troubling that seems to flash back and have some affect on the current case, many times w/devastating effects. Let‘s see what happens in #6. #SeriesLove2023 @Andrew65 @TheSpineView

Andrew65 You have done brilliantly with these. Well done 🥳 Always sad when you are approaching the end of a good series. 1y
deeannloso @Andrew65 Thanks so much! 😊 1y
TheSpineView Well done! 1y
deeannloso @TheSpineView Thanks! 😊 1y
43 likes4 comments
blurb
deeannloso
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

“A year ago a boy was found murdered at a girlsʼ boarding school, and the case was never solved. Detective Stephen Moran has been waiting for his chance to join Dublin‘s Murder Squad when sixteen-year-old Holly Mackey arrives in his office with a photo of the boy with the caption: ‘I KNOW WHO KILLED HIM.‘” #SeriesLove2023

37 likes3 stack adds
review
SheilaChew
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

First book of 2023! This took me awhile to read because I couldn‘t figure out the writer‘s style. By the end, though, I got it and liked it. This complicated story about a group of four friends at boarding school and a brutal murder of a young man was interesting and I didn‘t figure it out until the end.

review
Tertubotn
Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Panpan

My least favorite of the Dublin Murder Squad series, and the last of the six I read. All the books have detailed descriptlons of the environment where the crime happens, so they move slow. Most of the time it works, here it just makes the book boring.

review
Amoon
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Bailedbailed

I‘ve been hearing about Tana French for a long time. Reading on a tablet, didn‘t realize it was over 900 pages. Kept waiting for it to get better, Never did even after the murder was solved. Set at an exclusive boarding school where (of course) all any of them want to do is break the rules and maybe have sex. I didn‘t find any of the characters interesting. Wish I had bailed sooner.

blurb
Susanita
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

1. Mystery
2. Set in a #boardingschool 😎
3. Agatha Christie, Sue Grafton, Val McDermid, Louise Penny
#sundayfunday
#savvysettings

Eggs Thanks for the tag ❤️❤️ 2y
BookmarkTavern Agatha Christie is an amazing choice! Thanks for posting! 2y
47 likes2 comments
blurb
Susanita
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

1. I prefer single POV but also like multiple POV when it‘s done well. Tagged book was a good audiobook read by two different narrators, even though they pronounced Costello differently!
2. Yes for school but not so much for personal reading.
3. I make lists then decide what to read by mood…or by what‘s due at the library first.
#wondrouswednesday

Eggs Thanks for joining in 🥳📚👍🏼 2y
33 likes1 comment
review
bekakins
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

This wasn‘t my favourite Murder Squad novel, but it was still pretty bloody good. Teenage girls are scary… I‘m so glad my parents didn‘t send me to our local all girls school when I asked them not to!

And here‘s #bookspin #doublespin #bookspinbingo for Feb! I got a line in Jan so fingers crossed for the same!

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! I also can't imagine surviving an all-girls school 😂 2y
10 likes1 comment
blurb
DarkMina
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Eggs Great pick! 2y
17 likes1 comment
review
BethHagey
Secret Place | Tana French
Pickpick

****

blurb
GatheringBooks
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

A book that #BeginsWith #Secret Day 3: part of Tana French‘s book series.

Eggs Great choice!! 2y
49 likes1 comment
review
AlizaApp
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

So glad to be back with the Dublin murder squad, though I am not sure this one was my favorite. It all unfolds over the course of one day, which I liked, and brings back Detective Stephen Moran and Holly Mackey (Frank‘s daughter), now all grown up and in high school. A mysterious note shows up that might be related to a murder, and Holly brings it to Moran who sees his chance to jump to the Murder squad.

review
Coleen
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

I‘m working my way through these (Dublin Murder Squad) in order, and each time I finish one I think it‘s my favorite. Yet when I look back at all of them as a series, I‘m not sure I could pic a favorite. They‘re all good and unique. I liked this one because it was set in a girls boarding school. I seem to be a sucker for those.

jhod This was the first one I read (I then went back!) And it's still my fave, am also a sucker for a school story! 2y
24 likes1 comment
review
Bibliotekate
Secret Place | Tana French
Pickpick

Perhaps my favorite of French‘s series.

blurb
Branwen
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Ta dah! My book haul for the weekend! 🎉💕📚 #bookhaul

Weisubei Love we ride the storm trilogy ❤️ 3y
Branwen @Weisubei It looks amazing! I can't wait to start it! I had never heard if it before but the covers really drew me in! 3y
51 likes2 comments
review
Jas16
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

It has been a year since a boy was found murdered in a girls‘ boarding school and Stephen Moran must wade through all of the cliques, mean girls, and teenage drama to help find the killer if he wants a shot at a spot on the Murder Squad. My least favorite book in the series so far for a variety of reasons. Even still I got sucked in and kept trying to guess the ending.
#charactersarefrenemies #booked2021

Reggie Aww I like the pic! 🌱 3y
Jas16 @Reggie Thanks Reggie! 3y
56 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
crhealey
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

We‘re back in school after a week of online learning so it is back to early morning reading and a #dailydunkin #teachersofLitsy

15 likes1 stack add
blurb
crhealey
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Continuing to chip away at this one. Took a drive and ended up an hour away from my house with a new view and an apple cider chai. #weekendreads

blurb
crhealey
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Soaking up every possible minute at outdoor cafes before winter comes. #weekendreads #dublinmurderseries

blurb
Laughterhp
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

#BookReport - Finished 2 books this week and started 3 books this week.

I‘m 50 pages into my #LMPBC book. The MC already annoys me so 😬😬😂

I‘m over 100 pages into Magic Burns. I really love this work and Kate Daniel‘s snark.

I‘m listening to Truth or Beard on audio. I‘ve never read Penny Reid before but I‘m liking the romance.

#WeeklyForecast - Honestly no idea what I‘ll read next but it‘ll be off #bookspinbonanza list

Amandajoy I love the Winston Brothers series on audio! 4y
Cinfhen I listened to the Friends book on audio / it was really good!!! 4y
Laughterhp @Amandajoy I didn‘t like the woman narrator at first because of her accent but it grew on me! 4y
Laughterhp @Cinfhen Oh that‘s good to hear! I have a hard copy of the book. 4y
50 likes4 comments
review
Laughterhp
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

It was so good to be back in the world of Ireland and the Murder squad. Such a great mystery. I didn‘t know who the murder was going to be. I know a lot of people didn‘t care for the supernatural elements, but I didn‘t have any issues with it. It made an interesting storyline.

I have 2 left I think in the Murder Squad.

#BookSpinBonanza - Book 4 or 5 (I have to double check 😬, this was the 5th number picked)

vivastory There's only one more after that in the DMS 4y
vivastory The following one is not a part of DMS 4y
Laughterhp @vivastory I‘m totally reading them out of order 😂 I still have the Likeness and the Trespasser left. I honestly don‘t really know what the order is. 4y
See All 9 Comments
vivastory You're in for a treat! Those are tied as my number 1 favorite with Broken Harbor slightly behind. 4y
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! Great progress!!! 4y
Laughterhp @vivastory That‘s good to hear! Broken Harbor has been my favorite so far, with In The Woods behind it. 4y
MyNamesParadise This has been on my to read list for so long and I think my next read. I want a good book to read. My favorite of the Dublin Murder Squad is Faithful Place (I‘ve only read the first 4 so far.) 4y
UrsulaMonarch Beautiful picture! I‘m in the middle of this one 😊 3y
Laughterhp @UrsulaMonarch I hope you‘re liking it!! 3y
61 likes9 comments
review
janeycanuck
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

I loved how the current day timeline happened all in one day! French is masterful at unfurling little bits of the story in just the right way to keep your mind constantly flipping between suspects. I could have done without the supernatural element, I just didn‘t see how that added to the story.

Book 5 for #bookspinbonanza

TheAromaofBooks Ooo great review! I've only ever read one of French's books, but keep meaning to try another! 4y
janeycanuck @TheAromaofBooks most people say The Likeness is their favourite but I think Faithful Place is mine. She‘s so good! 4y
marleed Your bath is so beautiful! 4y
janeycanuck @marleed thank you! 4y
35 likes4 comments
blurb
Laughterhp
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

It was not nice out today. Some sun, lots of clouds and lots of wind. 😬😬

But we were working outside today at a friends house and obviously are not able to hang out inside. I had a winter hat, a vest, a long sleeves shirt, and a jacket/sweater on 😂😂

So I laid on their hammock and got a few chapters in.

#NutsInMay #dogsoflitsy

Also, apparently I was more concerned about getting Buddy in the picture than my book 🤷🏻‍♀️🤪

Andrew65 It was very cool and windy here too, I didn‘t head outside at all. 4y
78 likes1 comment
review
erzascarletbookgasm
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

French captures the adolescent girls‘ relationships very well..the angst, intensity, bitching, young love, secrets...right down to the annoying teens talk (“OhmyGod!” “awesomesauce”). Intricately plotted, character driven & a great sense of place. I love when French writes about her detectives, this time, an odd-pair & an appearance of Frank Mackey (my fav). Fantastic read, my only complaint in the comments.

#mandmchallenge2020 #favoriteauthor

erzascarletbookgasm The story could very well do away with the paranormal (magical realism?) element. 👎 4y
Cathythoughts Nice review 👍🏻❤️ I saw somewhere on Litsy she has a new one coming out in the Autumn 😁 4y
erzascarletbookgasm @Cathythoughts I‘m so excited for it then! I only have one more of hers to read 4y
See All 11 Comments
BarbaraTheBibliophage Great job! I have one of her first books on my shelf and really should read it already!! 4y
Laughterhp Just took this one of my bookshelf the other day and added it to my to be read soon pile. 4y
heatherkaz @ezrascarletbookgasm I agree with you, I could have done without it too. I get it, French incorporated bits of the paranormal in other stories, but I didn't love the way it was done in The Secret Place. 4y
erzascarletbookgasm @Laughterhp I hope you‘ll like it! 4y
erzascarletbookgasm @heatherkaz I remember when I first read In The Woods, I was confused with the bits of paranormal but I‘m glad to have continued the series. I love the Dublin Murder Squad! 4y
heatherkaz @ezrascarletbookgasm This is by far one of my favorite series! 4y
BookDragonNotWorm I agree completely! This one and In The Woods are my favorite in the series, but they'd hit harder if they were firmly grounded in reality. 4y
erzascarletbookgasm @BookDragonNotWorm My favourite is The Faithful Place. This one comes close, if only the paranormal part is omitted. Broken Harbour is very good too. 4y
75 likes2 stack adds11 comments
blurb
Kaylamburson
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Debate! I just left a meeting where there was a hot debate about the effectiveness of step-back covers (a paperback cover that is trimmed slightly shorter to reveal the page underneath filled with reviews and awards). As a general reader, do you pay attention to review blurbs? Do they help convince you to buy a book? Have you ever even noticed a step-back cover? If so, is that more meaningful than just one blurb on the front?

Chrissyreadit I do not look at them. 4y
kstadt929 I purposely skip over them because I don‘t really care what they say at all! I would not choose a book based on these (or put it back if I was planning to buy it!) 4y
BookishMarginalia I look at them but it really only sways me if an author I love and trust gives a blurb that feels authentic. 4y
See All 14 Comments
MyNamesParadise I look at them out of curiosity to see what writers have given reviews but it doesn‘t determine if I buy the book, although lately I‘ve been getting my books from the library. Haven‘t bought a book in a while! 4y
IamIamIam I don't trust any reviews because I don't think they're honest. I dislike those kinds of covers, though!!! Lol 4y
Kaylamburson Hahaha, you don't trust any reviews, or just ones from other authors. Do you trust those from publications? And do you dislike the covers because of the aesthetic? @IamIamIam. I do personally hate how it feels in my hands. 4y
Hazel2019 I try my best not to buy books with step-back covers. They take away from the cover and make the book look cheap imo. I do read the review blurbs though. My preference is for them to be on the back cover. I enjoy the language they use. You can pick up some neat phrases 😁 4y
Jas16 I really don‘t like step-back covers at all and prefer not to buy them. Thanks for teaching me what they are called! 4y
Amie I don't read the review blurbs on books, and I don't like the way step back covers look (but now I know what they're called - I didn't know that term before). 4y
rockpools I find them odd. I‘m more likely to look at review blurbs in an advert or on a poster - once the book‘s in my hands I won‘t even glance at them - the cover/blurb/writing will help me decide whether to take it home. 4y
Hooked_on_books I don‘t like step-back covers at all. I find them unattractive and they can make the book unwieldy. I rarely pay any attention to blurbs anywhere on a book. I either already know I want to read a book or I simply read the description on the back cover or flap. 4y
Billypar I never use blurbs/reviews to help me decide on a book (opposite of movies where I do rely on critic reviews). When I was a teenager I was fascinated with blurbs - I would read and re-read them while reading the novel. Like they got me more excited somehow. Now I just glance at them sometimes but don't pay much mind. Not a big step-back cover fan either (though cool to know there's a word for those!) 4y
minkyb Don't look at them. Certainly never influences whether I will purchase the book.
4y
Kaylamburson Thanks all!! I love hearing all your thoughts about them. As a general consumer I never paid them any attention either. But so glad I was able to teach a bunch of you a new term! Haha.@chrissyreadit @kstadt929 @BookishMarginalia @MyNamesParadise @IamIamIam @Hazel2019 @jas16 @Amie @RachelO @Hooked_on_books @Billypar @minkyb 4y
55 likes14 comments
blurb
GatheringBooks
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

#MagnificentMarch Day 17: Tana French definitely fits the #IrishAuthorSetInIreland theme. Bought all of her books in this series while I was in Dublin. How could I possibly resist that marked-down price? More of my book haul while in Ireland here: https://wp.me/pDlzr-iLv

Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks I‘ve never read her books! 🤦🏼‍♀️ 4y
OriginalCyn620 I‘ve never read her books either but I watched The Dublin Murders on Stars and loved it! 🖤 4y
61 likes2 comments
review
djlewis78
The Secret Place | Tana French
Panpan

This is my least favorite book in the series. Unfortunately, I think I‘m done with this series as the books have not gotten any better. The first book was fantastic but they‘ve steadily declined.

blurb
AshleyKorinE
The Secret Place | Tana French

I have a new challenge video out!

https://youtu.be/eBtPOnWGGa0

blurb
Cathythoughts
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

#WeeklyForcast

Started tagged book early this morning in bed & in the dark ... kindles are good like that ! So glad to be back on the crime scene

Also these 2 Curtis Sittenfelds are looking good !

And there are books wrapped up under the tree ... soooo 🤷🏼‍♀️ who knows where this weeks reading will go

Lovely to be reading Tana again ❤️

Cathythoughts @Cinfhen I must study the #booked2020 lists ... it will be new year soon & Id love to start one on New Years Day 🥳 4y
TrishB @Cathythoughts that‘s such a good idea 👍🏻 4y
Cinfhen I really enjoyed Eligible it was a cute retelling of P&P but I wasn‘t too crazy about 4y
See All 7 Comments
Cinfhen All 3 Sittenfeld books are very different from each other, I‘m including American Wife 4y
Cathythoughts @Cinfhen thanks! Forewarned is good 👍🏻❤️ 4y
LeahBergen I better find some books under the tree, too. 😆 4y
Cathythoughts @LeahBergen Ofcorse you will 👍🏻❤️❤️ 4y
47 likes7 comments
review
Pamwurtzler
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

I liked this, but maybe not as much as her others. It seemed to move more slowly. But, still very good!

blurb
rachelm
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Getting ready for a family picture! Listening to this one from French‘s Dublin Murder Squad series, and while it‘s not my favorite, there are some strangely supernatural elements that make it feel perfect for Halloween 🎃

36 likes1 comment
review
Molly_the_mezzo
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

I very much liked this one. High school was awful and this captured that intense desperation for me. The detective was very likable. The bit of supernatural weirdness was odd, and for me it was never properly defined whether that was real or not, but maybe that was ok? Any A+

73 likes3 stack adds
review
Tonton
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

Gilded youth in boarding school angst as Dublin Murder Squad‘s Antoinette Conway and Stephen Moran partner up for one day to follow up on a clue in the death of a golden schoolboy one year ago. Conway gives no quarter, Moran is all about using this chance to move onto the squad. Heady, secret,and dangerous teenage world seems impossible to parse. Don‘t think I would have survived high school now. Now for French‘s next one🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

erzascarletbookgasm I just finished reading this! Great review. The only thing that stopped me from giving it full stars..the paranormal element. 4y
44 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
DHill
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Back to the Dublin Murder Squad for me. I‘m enjoying this one on audio.

58 likes1 stack add
blurb
LeslieO
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

I love Harney and Sons hot cinnamon spice. #teatime #polarvortex2019 #snowday

booksandsympathy Sounds delicious 5y
LeahBergen I really need to try this tea! 5y
Samplergal I love their earl grey and African herbal tea. Yum. 5y
LeslieO @Samplergal The only other one I‘ve tried is the holiday blend, which I 💕💕 5y
59 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
LeslieO
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Experimenting with tracking my reading with the Bookly app. I love reading to the sound of "light rain". The actual weather is another story. It hasn't stop snowing since yesterday morning. Current temp is 2 degrees with -15 wind chill. Back to my book and gentle rain! #snowday #readallday

DHill How are you liking the book so far? I just started it on audio. 5y
LeslieO @DHill I'm loving it! Got behind on my Dublin Murder Squad. 5y
AmyG I read to that, too. My husband works out of our home....which for now is a small apartment. So I put rains sounds on to drown him out so I can read. 5y
LauraBeth I can feel the chill in that pic - stay warm! I started using Bookly at the beginning of the month and have found that I really like it. I thought I‘d stop using it after one or two books but have been consistent with it. 5y
51 likes4 comments
blurb
DHill
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Grateful for a new audiobook to get me to work on this ridiculously cold day.

Cortg Ugh! I can‘t imagine. Bundle up and stay warm 5y
DHill Thanks @Cortg ! It doesn‘t feel much warmer at work. My little space heater can barely keep up. 🥶 5y
Lynnsoprano I‘m cold by Florida standards, but nothing like that! Take care. 5y
DHill Thanks @Lynnsoprano ! It‘s still -25 right now but at least we‘re on the upward trend. 5y
58 likes4 comments
review
ErinC
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

Another great book #setinireland #irishauthor completed for #booked2019. This one seemed different than the rest of the Dublin Murder Squad series. I liked it, but toward the end it drug on. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

vivastory This is my least favorite of the Dublin Murder Squad series. The next one is one of my favorites though. 5y
Cinfhen I just read my first French (and probably my last) I was a little bored by all the cop shop talk... but she definitely nails the Irish prompt 💚 5y
68 likes2 comments
blurb
ErinC
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

Finally had a chance to write down my much too lofty January goals! Hopefully I get through at least half. I like options. Plus all my holds came it at the same time, so I‘ve got a giant stack from the library to pick up.

Bookwormjillk I loved Americanah 5y
ErinC @Bookwormjillk I‘m enjoying it so far! About 100 pages in! 5y
64 likes2 comments
review
whatsthEStorey
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image
Pickpick

First book of the year & one down for #Booked2019! I love Tana French. This mystery takes place at an expensive boarding school for girls. The atmosphere is intense. The girls are at once predatory and dangerous and insecure children in too much makeup. The twists keep coming until the very end.

#FemaleDetective

Cinfhen Is this a stand alone or part of her Dublin Murder Squad series??? It sounds really good 5y
whatsthEStorey @Cinfhen it‘s number five in the series, which I did not realize until I was reading it! There were a few parts where I could tell I was missing some back story, but overall it didn‘t affect my reading. Most people said this was their least favorite of the series, so if this is her worst, I definitely need to go back and start at the beginning! 5y
TrishB This was definitely my least favourite! 5y
alisiakae I plan on starting this series as soon as I finish up Jo Nesbø‘s Harry Hole series! 5y
63 likes2 stack adds4 comments
blurb
Craftylikefox
The Secret Place | Tana French
post image

2019 starts off with these two!! Already halfway through Tinder and it‘s a lot like a Grimm Fairytale. Enjoying it very much!

55 likes2 stack adds