Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Dictionary of Lost Words
The Dictionary of Lost Words | Pip Williams
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
quote
TheBookgeekFrau
post image

"Before the lost word, there was another."

#FirstLineFriday
@ShyBookOwl

Just started this

review
Allthebookclubs
post image
Pickpick

A story about words and the life of Esme Nicoll. A little slow to get started but I found myself wanting to know what‘s next with her. I wish the title included the lost words were women‘s words. Many people talk about wishing they‘d been born during a more simple time, but I (and this book) will tell you the turn of the 20th century wasn‘t simple for anyone. Book #56 in 2023

review
Elizabeth2
post image
Pickpick

This historical novel is about the journey to make sure that the influence of women on words is not lost. Esme‘s father is a lexicographer working on the first edition of the Oxford English Dictionary. Esme begins to collect, and eventually compiles her own dictionary of, words related to women‘s experiences. Inspired by actual events, the story takes place during the women‘s suffrage movement. It started slow, but became unputdownable. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5

review
Adventures-of-a-French-Reader
post image
Pickpick

This book is an invitation to think about words. Who uses them, how they are used by different people, who records them, who gets to define them, who chooses to include them in dictionaries, etc.

Well-written, with an engaging and well-constructed plot, I'm sure this book will seduce numerous word lovers.

review
CBee
post image
Pickpick

This was a slow read, but one to be savored. I very much loved this book, and love that it‘s based on the publication of the Oxford English Dictionary (which I really knew nothing about). Thanks to @Sapphire for including this in her #ALspine list, and thanks to @monalyisha for the great match 💚

CBee Also, this was my #bookspin for July @TheAromaofBooks 2mo
jen_the_scribe I loved this one too, and agree wholeheartedly about needing to savor it ❤️ 2mo
CBee @jen_the_scribe it took me longer than usual to read which is usually the universe telling me to slow down 💚 2mo
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! 2mo
76 likes3 stack adds4 comments
blurb
Elizabeth2
post image

Current situation. #frontporchsitting #reading #sunshine #sundayvibes ❤️📚

blurb
Elizabeth2
post image

Sunday vibes. #porchsitting #frontporchreading #sundayfunday 😎❤️📚

blurb
Elizabeth2
post image

Next read is for book club! It was my pick this month, and this one piqued my interest! ❤️📚

review
LadyCait84
post image
Pickpick

Edged by a So-So to a be Pick, but I‘d honestly hoped for more from this one. The narrative feels uneven — with the protagonist‘s formative years seeming drawn out & thoroughly detailed, while the latter years are blurred & rushed despite having such ginormous events as an escalating suffragette movement & WWI to give it focus & weight. Still, the book‘s igniting questions of what & who determines words worthy of record is certainly interesting.

review
Pogue
post image
Pickpick

This was a great fictional account of the creation of the Oxford English Dictionary. What words were left out and why. It also covers what life was like for women at that time.

JaneyWaneyB I loved this book and I may have shed a few tears whilst reading it 😭💖📚 6mo
26 likes1 comment
blurb
AReedCollett
post image

Next row in my #readinglogsnake is for another #rplbooksandbrews read, The Dictionary of Lost Words by Pip Williams. Yellow representing historical fiction. Before the English woman's suffrage, the MC captures words in an attempt to make a dictionary of women's words, and ends up with an interesting Edwardian urban dictionary. Interesting, yet sad read. 4/5 ⭐️ #ARRCReads #BooksAndCrafts

review
DaniJ
Pickpick

Lovely, if slightly slow, historical fiction that includes women‘s rights, the Oxford English Dictionary, and multiple definitions of love.

review
jen_the_scribe
post image
Pickpick

A bit of a scholarly read but still fiction. Per the author‘s note, a lot of the side characters were based on actual lexicographers/editors at the Oxford English Dictionary during that time. At the root of it, this is a love letter to words, specifically those of women and other people often overlooked and underestimated. There‘s a lot of life in this story, a lot of grief and plenty of love. Words bringing it all together. Lovely story overall.

review
Rachiiebookdragon
Pickpick

I listened to this one via BorrowBox,
It was interesting.

Read for reading challenges

4.25/5

quote
jen_the_scribe

“The war has made the present more important than the past, and far more certain than the future…”

quote
jen_the_scribe

“Words are our tools of resurrection.”

blurb
jen_the_scribe
post image

My next listen… 😊

17 likes1 stack add
review
PageShifter
post image
Pickpick

I liked Esme and loved Lizzie! But I still think that some of the characters should have been more fleshed out. There were sad twists but they left me a bit cold.

This felt a bit claustrophobic because the setting was the same almost the whole time. It was well created but at least those scenes that happened outside could have been more vivid.

I loved how this was based on real events and this was interesting story.

27 likes1 comment
review
Sargar114
post image
Mehso-so

You follow the life of Esme Nichols which in essence mirrors the publication of the Oxford English Dictionary. Esme starts gathering words that don‘t seemingly make it in. The author is looking at the gender and social bias reasons for this. The story itself was fine, the afterward was the most interesting part for me. Picked up because of #literarycrew Did the audiobook and enjoyed the narration.

22 likes1 stack add
quote
PageShifter

“Words are our tools of resurrection.”

review
Hillea2
Mehso-so

Esme‘s strength impressed me, so having the book have little redemption for her was hard. But a book with so many women who feel empowered without a husband was refreshing!

blurb
kspenmoll
post image

#12booksof2022 #May2022 #toppickofthemonth
This is a lyrical,evocative book.Esme spent her childhood capturing word slips that floated from the table where Lexicographers,including her Da sat,making decisions about which words merited inclusion in the Oxford English. Dictionary. Overtime,she noted that words spoken by the common people or women were not included.She spent her life chasing down those very words.🔽

kspenmoll 🔼This book sent me down the research rabbit hole which was fun. https://www.murrayscriptorium.org/commentaries/com-women-contributors.shtml (edited) 9mo
Andrew65 Always love it when a book leads you down research rabbit holes. 9mo
kspenmoll @Andrew65 Yes!💜 9mo
66 likes4 comments
blurb
mcctrish
post image

For May #12booksof2022 I had a few 5 star reads, but this one stands out for me for its cover, it‘s story about the Oxford English Dictionary ( I‘m slightly obsessed about books about it) and a word that goes missing AND the main character is a girl that is allowed to follow a bit of an unconventional path

Andrew65 Good choice. 9mo
40 likes1 comment
review
ICantImReading
post image
Mehso-so

⭐️⭐️⭐️

This is a well-researched and thought-provoking love letter to language. If affluent white men determine which words are “real” and “worthy”, what words and stories are lost? I am glad I read this, but I also admit that it wasn‘t a super exciting story to me personally. 🎧 #reesesbookclub

Librariana Which words are omitted... who isn't represented, who's excluded. I agree 💯% that it was indeed a thought-provoking yet slow read. I enjoyed it and jotted down a few things while reading it, but I don't know if it is one I'll revisit. 10mo
ICantImReading @Librariana same here! I‘m glad we found things to appreciate even if it wasn‘t a favorite ☺️ 10mo
55 likes2 comments
review
rwmg
post image
Pickpick

Esme's single father is one of Dr. James Murray's assistants in the compilation of the OED, so she grows up in Murray's Scriptorium. Later she comes to realise the dictionary's focus on the written word excludes the words used by those who are not members of the literary elite.

A little slow at first but draws the reader in and does a good job in the balancing act of making Esme a believable 19thC woman with a more 21stC attitude to lexicography.

blurb
rwmg
post image
blurb
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks
post image

Thank you so much Amy for this awesome birthday package!! Love everything!! Can‘t wait to read these books! 📚❤️📚

#LitsyLove
#Bookmail is the best mail!!

AmyG 😘you are so welcome. Happy Belated Birthday! 11mo
Lynnsoprano Wow! What wonderful books! 11mo
Suet624 Happy belated birthday! 11mo
See All 7 Comments
Teresereading I haven‘t seen those little sweets for so long 11mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @Lynnsoprano yes!! Amy is amazing! 11mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @Teresereading I‘m hiding them 🤣🤣🤣 11mo
86 likes1 stack add7 comments
blurb
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks
post image

Thank you @EadieB !! I almost bought this one yesterday! I‘ve heard it‘s really good! Thank you so much!! 📚🧡

EadieB You're welcome! Hope you have a great birthday! 12mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @EadieB thank you 💞💞 12mo
63 likes2 comments
blurb
Librariana
post image

Outdoor reading setup during a work break.

I don't know what compelled me to take notes while reading the September #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead, but here we are! 😊

I genuinely hoped I could've contributed to the discussion in a timely manner, but I'm slowly realizing (and trying to make peace with the fact!) that I'm not a fast reader. I'm well-intentioned, I think, but I get lost in details and am also easily distracted by life.

@Librarybelle

EvieBee Just lovely! 12mo
Librarybelle There is no problem with that! 12mo
21 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
Librarybelle
post image
Pickpick

There is much to consider in this book about words…Williams looks at the creation of the OED, but through the lens of women involved in the project. Esme‘s entire life is wrapped around the dictionary, and she becomes a collector of words. It might sound mean, but there were times in the book that I got a little tired of Esme. She has a good heart, but she was not a favorite character of mine. I loved Ditte! ⬇️⬇️⬇️

Librarybelle 🔼🔼🔼And the concept behind a dictionary of lost words is so interesting. Parts of the narrative dragged for me, and the ending was somewhat unexpected. But, a good read overall. I‘m a few days late for the #LiteraryCrew discussion, but I plan to jump into the questions soonish! 12mo
Mccall0113 Loved this one! 12mo
Librariana I know I'm a month late ? to the discussion ?, but I so greatly enjoyed this book and much like you, @Librarybelle, I also found the concept behind a "Dictionary of Lost Words" so fascinating! There was a part of me though that constantly questioned Esme... wondered why SHE didn't question the exclusion of certain words a little more... but then I had to remind myself of the time this was taking place in... 11mo
Librariana One of my favorite parts was Gareth's engagement gift to Esme 🥰 But I was quite saddened when reading about his passing... and hers, too. I didn't necessarily expect a happy ending, but part of me felt like both of them deserved one. 11mo
Librarybelle @Librariana So glad you liked this one! And yes…the engagement gift…❤️❤️❤️☺️ 11mo
88 likes5 comments
review
Bluebird
post image
Pickpick

1. I love words.
2. I am interested in the different meanings of words & I started perusing the OED when in high school.
3. I enjoyed Simon Winchester‘s book about the making of the dictionary when I read it years ago.
4. I ❤️ historical fiction.
So, one could say I was predisposed to like this book. Lol

I didn‘t like it. I LOVED it. Thought provoking and beautifully written. It exceeded my expectations. This one will stay with me for awhile.

14 likes1 stack add
blurb
Librarybelle
post image

I was able to post the questions before work! Random House has an amazing list of thought provoking questions, so I posted just a sample. Note that some definitely require spoiler answers. Questions can be found on my feed, the book‘s feed, or by searching #LiteraryCrew .

Anything else you wish to discuss? Did you like/dislike the book? I know some of you are still reading or haven‘t snagged a copy yet…post whenever!

Thanks for joining!

Librarybelle And, if you wish to be tagged for next month‘s book and haven‘t had an opportunity to tell me yet, let me know! 12mo
julieclair Can‘t wait to join in once I finish the book! 😀 12mo
CarolineLovesToRead Still finishing this one. Hope to be done by tonight 12mo
megnews I‘d had this on my tbr for awhile. No telling when I might have gotten to it. Glad you chose it! Enjoyed discussion. 12mo
PurpleyPumpkin Yup, I‘m still reading this one too! I‘ll be sure to take a look at the questions when I‘m done. 😉 12mo
57 likes5 comments
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

8. Can the evolution of language ever be a bad thing? ~from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

AnnR Well, the word 'thongs' meant one thing when I was a kid and now means something completely different. I guess, judge for yourself if one definition is an improvement over the other, lol. 12mo
megnews I think not. It is always growing and changing like everything else. 12mo
Bluebird 🤣 @Ann_Reads i think the evolution of words is always good..as long as we keep the history and can look back on the changes. Not erasing the old. 12mo
7 likes3 comments
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

7. This book explores linguistic inequality - the idea that not all words are equal. To what extent do you think this phenomenon exists in modern English? ~from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

megnews VERY much so. African Americans developed AAVE out of a need to survive. I‘m no expert but it is a creative twist with defined rules and reasons but is very much judged in schools and the general public. AAVE and certain accents or colloquialisms, such as that of “hillbillies” is deemed to mean inferior intelligence which is not necessarily at all the case. 12mo
6 likes1 comment
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

6. Consider Esme and Lizzie‘s relationship. In what ways are the women similar? How are they different? ~from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

CoverToCoverGirl Esme is curious and questioning-Lizzie is quietly resigned to her circumstances. 12mo
5 likes1 comment
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

5. Do you think this is a hopeful story? Why or why not? ~from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

CoverToCoverGirl Yes. It shows the human spirit is resilient and that we are connected to and influenced by past events. History has a way of influencing and changing our future. The ripple effect. 12mo
megnews I think so. It shows that the underdog can find ways to salvage their history or world despite attempted erasure by those in power as so many have had to do. And that‘s important. 12mo
5 likes2 comments
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

4. Is the ending of the book just? Do the characters get what they deserve? ~from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

CoverToCoverGirl Good not just. No. Life isn‘t a fairytale and bad things happen to good people. For me it made the story more realistic and impactful. Life happens and we can only move forward, hoping we make the right decisions. (edited) 12mo
megnews I didn‘t care for the ending. Like @CoverToCoverGirl I appreciate realistic over a tidy wrap up. But this ending felt too quick to me. Perhaps we didn‘t need to make it all the way to the end of Esme‘s life. I didn‘t feel enough closure on the story of her daughter to justify rushing through the end of her life. 12mo
Bluebird I liked the ending. Esme‘s work was not just lost to history upon her death and showed a longer standing meaning to all her efforts. 12mo
5 likes3 comments
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

3. How do you think not having a mother influenced the trajectory of Esme‘s life and her character? ~from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

AnnR It seemed most of Esme's role models were from the Scriptoriam and she had a rather unconventional upbringing. Her closest female role model was Lizzie. Even though Lizzie wasn't that much older than Esme, she provided some stabilizing and emotional support. 12mo
megnews Esme seemed like her father‘s daughter and a young girl on a different path from most. Still, the presence of her mother could have shifted that trajectory to some degree. I was very glad she had Ditte. (edited) 12mo
Bluebird I think she would have been an entirely different person. I suspect she would have had minimal exposure to the Scriptorium and would have been more involved in ‘women‘s work‘. She may have still had a love of words from her time with her father, but she wouldn‘t have sat below the sorting table and likely never have found the slip of paper with the word ‘bond maiden‘ 12mo
5 likes3 comments
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

2. What does this book tell us about power? ~adapted from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

CoverToCoverGirl As history has shown, men controlled the narrative, even for the most part the compilation of the Oxford dictionary. Having the final say as to what words were acceptable to the ruling class and discounting the words used by the lower classes. Power and influence. 12mo
megnews Absolutely agree with @CoverToCoverGirl It‘s a little surprising, though, that academics, who one would think would have an interest in fully documenting the world, would actively choose to leave things out. 12mo
5 likes2 comments
blurb
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me

1. The book essentially asks this…do words mean different things to men and women? And if they do, is it possible that we have lost something in the process of defining them? ~from Book Club Kit, Random House #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead

AnnR I think words can mean different things to men and women. The meaning of words can also be influenced by one's life experiences, such as Esme versus Lizzie. Even today, some accepted meanings of words might be completely overlooked in the official dictionaries, until an updated edition is published. 12mo
CoverToCoverGirl Yes. I think words can resonate and have different meanings to an individual just based on each person‘s life story and emotional make up. Words influence us. 12mo
megnews I agree with @Ann_Reads & @CoverToCoverGirl that words mean different things to men and women and also from culture to culture. 12mo
Bluebird Yes! Agree with you all. Words can mean different things to different people based on sex, culture and individual experience. The meaning of words can change for one individual depending upon their stage of life. Ex. As a child, the word ‘love‘ meant something different to me than it does today. 12mo
Bluebird Although flawed, I think defining words is an important way we can have some sort of common basis to interact and understand one another. We just need to be cognizant that not all will agree with the definitions and that frequent revisions and updates are necessary though. 12mo
6 likes5 comments
blurb
Librarybelle
post image

Just a reminder that the #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead discussion for the tagged book will be on Friday! Fair warning - I‘ve had some complications at work, so the discussion questions may get up in the evening Eastern Time rather than the morning. But, they will be posted!

I‘ve seen lots of great posts about this one…looking forward to the discussion!

PageShifter I finally got the book but propably not going to make it before the discussion 😒 12mo
Librarybelle No worries, @PageShifter ! Feel free to jump into the discussion whenever! 12mo
Sargar114 Still #21 in line for hold at my library, so not making this month. Should be able to make next month though! 12mo
See All 8 Comments
Librarybelle Wow, @Sargar114 …good luck getting a copy! It‘s become pretty popular all of a sudden in my library system too. 12mo
Jerdencon I‘m still waiting for my copy from the library - but will join once I finish it! 12mo
Librarybelle Sounds good, @Jerdencon ! 12mo
Librariana I was hoping to be finished with this by Friday, but health-related issues and work have gotten in the way a bit, slowing down my progress 😭 Plus hubby and I are getting our COVID booster/flu shot combo tomorrow evening! 😳 So needless to say, I think I might be out of commission on the energy department the next few days. I will certainly jump in once I can have something of value to contribute 😊 My apologies, @Librarybelle 💗 12mo
Librarybelle So sorry to hear that, @Librariana …jump in whenever you can! 12mo
46 likes1 stack add8 comments
review
megnews
post image
Pickpick

I really enjoyed this #LiteraryCrew pick about words and how they define us. The ending was a bit abrupt and unexpected. Looking forward to discussion.

Librarybelle So glad you liked this! 12mo
50 likes1 comment
blurb
ChantalReads
post image

Up next...?
Can't decide. What do y'all love?

quote
megnews
post image