Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#SherlockHolmes
review
Bookwomble
post image
Pickpick

Some years after ACD's death, a typewritten, unpublished Holmes story was found amongst his papers, titled “The Case of the Man who was Wanted“. Its discovery was reported, but the ACD estate said it would not see print as it was a somewhat inferior work. Outraged readers campaigned for its release and so persuaded (🤑💵) it was first published in USA.
Retired English architect, Arthur Whitaker, recognised the story as one he'd sent to ACD years⬇️

Bookwomble ... before, and received advice from the master to rewrite it without Holmes and publish it himself, or otherwise to accept 10 guineas to sell it as a story idea, which he did, with no guarantee ACD would actually use it, which he didn't.
The infamously litigious estate threatened to sue Whitaker over his claim of authorship, but relented when he provided proofs, and actually were good enough to give him the fee they'd received to help support ⬇️
(edited) 3h
Bookwomble ... his sick wife.
Summarised from this interesting article:
https://sheffielder.net/tag/arthur-whitaker/
So, the story: retitled for this collection “The Adventure of the Sheffield Banker“, far from being inferior, imho, it's a great addition to the canon. Holmes, Watson and Lestrade are well characterised, and the mystery gives Holmes some difficulties, which he naturally overcomes in classic style. I really liked it ?
(edited) 3h
AnnCrystal
🆒 interesting 🕵️‍♂️👍🏼 info 📚💫.
(edited) 3h
15 likes3 comments
review
Bookwomble
post image
Pickpick

The first story, "The Adventure of the First-Class Carriage" is by Monsignor Ronald A. Knox, a Catholic priest who wrote and critiqued detective fiction during the Golden Age of British crime writing, and is perhaps best known for his 10 rules of detective fiction. He also wrote a BBC radio play about a fictitious armed revolution in London in a documentary style which fooled many listeners into believing it was factual, and which Orson Welles ⬇️

Bookwomble ... acknowledged as an inspiration for his infamous War of the Worlds radio broadcast a few years later.
Anyway, the story has features which are not uninteresting, containing a number of evocative Holmesian elements, but it's all rather *too* elementary as Sherlock cracks the case quickly and it's all over before it's barely begun. I'd have liked it to have been longer and more developed, but not too bad a start. 3.5 🔎
5h
AnnCrystal 🆒🕵️‍♂️📚...the Orson Welles infamous radio broadcast 👏🏼😂👍🏼. 2h
20 likes2 comments
blurb
Bookwomble
post image

Lancelyn Green's story-by-story introduction is an informative read, setting the stage for his selection of homages to Holmes. He states that he has been careful to collect stories that are written as serious 'apocrypha' rather than parodies, so I'm hoping for some quality entries 🔎📖
Paganini's violin concertos 1 & 2 seemed an appropriate musical accompaniment 🎻
#BooksAndMusic

Bookwomble My bookmark choice isn't my Sherlock Holmes one, as that's seen a fair bit of action the past couple of years. However, as one of the stories is "The Adventure of the Trained Cormorant," this one featuring a cormorant amongst a flock of other sea birds seemed a fitting choice ?
#BookmarkMatching
6h
TrishB Great matching 👍🏻 3h
quietlycuriouskate I might have to start a list of marvellous story titles, though Ian McMillan's "The Diamond-Studded Triceratops" is going to take some beating. 2h
21 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
Bookwomble
post image

I see from my previous post for this book from two years ago that I celebrated finding it with a chippy dinner of pie, chips & gravy, seeing which has given me the midnight munchies! 😋
This anthology of pastiches was first published in 1985, the stories being drawn from the 1920s onwards.
Editor, Richard Lancelyn Green, was an acknowledged Holmesian expert, who at age 50 was found garroted to death with a shoelace tightened by a wooden spoon. ⬇️

Bookwomble He'd been engaged in an unsuccessful campaign to prevent the auction of some of ACD's papers, and had voiced concerns to family and friends about being stalked by an unidentified mysterious American. Theories about his death include murder and, in the mode of The Problem of Thor Bridge, an elaborate suicide made to look like murder. Either way a tragically sad end for a devoted Holmesian scholar. (edited) 15h
Bookwomble @Dabbe I apologise for not following the order of the group read you've kindly organised for Holmesian pastiches. I'm afraid I'm not very clubable; even the Diogenes won't have me! I will join in if there are any volumes that come up which I already own, if that's ok 😊 15h
LeahBergen And now I‘m craving a chippy dinner 😆 15h
Bookwomble @LeahBergen Yeah, something along those lines might happen for me tomorrow! 😁 15h
AnnCrystal Brilliant cover artwork 🎨🤩📚💫. 14h
24 likes5 comments
blurb
Blueberry
Holmes Entangled | Gordon McAlpine
post image

Buenas Aires
Argentina, 1943

Sr J.L. Borges, 44, has completed his shift at the ill-organized Miguel Cané Municipal Library, near the city center, where he works
as first assistant.

#FirstLineFridays
@ShyBookOwl

35 likes1 stack add
blurb
LitsyEvents
Time for Sherlock Holmes | David Dvorkin
post image

repost for @dabbe

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes @Cuilin #SHPasticheBuddyRead

Hello, Pastiche-Sherlockians! We have some voting to do for the titles we're going to read! The link is below. All are welcome to join us! Just comment below, and we'll add you to the list. More info will be coming once the results are tallied!

Link to the survey: https://forms.gle/SXBadrcMfYGDfxP58

Skygoddess1 Voted! 4d
dabbe TY! 🧡💜💛 3d
dabbe @Skygoddess1 YAY! 🧡💜💛 3d
27 likes3 comments
blurb
dabbe
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes @Cuilin @LitsyEvents
#SHPasticheBuddyRead

Hello, Pastiche-Sherlockians! We have some voting to do for the titles we're going to read! The link is below. All are welcome to join us! Just comment below, and we'll add you to the list. More info will be coming once the results are tallied!

Link to the survey: https://forms.gle/SXBadrcMfYGDfxP58

kspenmoll Finished voting! 6d
Librarybelle Voted! 6d
dabbe @kspenmoll YAY! 💛💜🧡 6d
See All 15 Comments
dabbe @Librarybelle YAY! 💛💜🧡 6d
kspenmoll Are you having your shoulder surgery tomorrow? If so, best of luck. 🩷🩵💚 5d
dabbe @kspenmoll I am! Thanks for remembering and for the well wishes. 🧡💜💛 5d
CogsOfEncouragement All done. Thank you so much for all your time and effort to put this together. I appreciate it and look forward to continued BR discussions with this group. 5d
dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement YAY! We do, too! 💛💜🧡 5d
kelli7990 I voted 5d
CatLass007 I don‘t plan to vote because I will just listen to whatever the group decides. But I‘ve looked at some of the choices and all of them look interesting. 5d
eeclayton Thank you, I voted! 4d
dabbe @kelli7990 YAY! 🧡💜💛 3d
dabbe @CatLass007 Cool beans! 🧡💜💛 3d
dabbe @eeclayton YAY! 🧡💜💛 3d
44 likes15 comments
blurb
LitsyEvents
Time for Sherlock Holmes | David Dvorkin
post image

repost for @dabbe

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
@Cuilin @LitsyEvents 🧡🖤💛

Friendly reminder to get your nominations in for our pastiche #BuddyRead beginning in October! Please fill out the survey below by Sunday (tomorrow). Then, I'll have the voting survey out early next week.
Survey link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSecT0ZHVYWiI8wqu2ePKW9x58srco0b5h655rlm...

dabbe TY! 💛💜🧡 6d
20 likes1 comment
review
dabbe
Sherlock Holmes Book | DK Publishing
post image
Pickpick

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
A visually rich companion to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle‘s legendary canon, this book aims to make Holmes‘ world accessible through infographics, summaries, and analysis. It does not disappoint. The book meticulously breaks down all four novels and 56 short stories, providing plot summaries, character bios, and thematic insights. ⬇️

dabbe True to DK‘s style, the book excels in design, featuring flowcharts, timelines, and illustrations that clarify Holmes‘ deductive reasoning and Victorian-era context. Two items of note: 1. Each story summary reveals key plot twists, making it unsuitable for readers who haven‘t yet experienced the original tales. 2. While informative, the analysis lacks the depth of specialized works like Leslie Klinger‘s THE NEW ANNOTATED SHERLOCK HOLMES. 7d
kspenmoll Fantastic review! 7d
dabbe @kspenmoll TY! It was such a fun and helpful book while rereading the canon! 💛💜🧡 7d
59 likes3 comments
blurb
LitsyEvents
Sherlock Holmes Book | DK Publishing
post image

Repost for @dabbe

Calling all Sherlockians and avid Holmes' fans!

Announcing the first-ever SH Pastiche Buddy Read! To help us create the best buddy read ever, please fill out the linked survey below by this Sunday, 8/17. Once it's compiled, we'll get back to you with the details!

Survey Link: https://forms.gle/at4jEGUfar1g4xjq7

Tagging those who showed an interest; ALL are welcome to join! Just comment below. The game's soon-to-be afoot! 🖤

dabbe TY! 🖤 2w
28 likes1 comment