Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#civilization
review
Tkgbjenn1
post image
Mehso-so

Not what I was expecting. The subtext of the title suggests a history of alcohol and how it brought people together to help create civilization. And there are interesting tidbits of information. Like how the drive to brew intoxicating beverages had as much to do with the rise of agriculture as food. But it‘s less about history and more about the science of alcohol and its effects. Science that often reads like a school textbook.

review
Parvez
Guns, Germs and Steel | Diamond, Jared
post image
Pickpick

Finished reading. Jared Diamond puts forward his thesis that geographical and environmental factors played a vital role in shaping certain regions. The last few chapters felt repetitive but overall a great book. 4/5

review
pr.alm
The Lessons of History | Will Durant, Ariel Durant
post image
Pickpick

A fountain of knowledge, thousands of years' worth of lessons distilled elegantly in a single short book. It does, however, expect the reader to have a fundamental familiarity with particular historical events and characters. Also, the authors get extra points for adding a touch of sarcasm to the narrative. Definitely a must read!

review
Johnanthonymiller
post image
Pickpick

The Age of Voltaire is book #9 of #11 in the Durants' History of Civilization series. Well-written and extremely detailed, the series is a must read for history lovers. Settle in for a long read though. Each volume is 800 -1000 pages.

review
IuliaC
Guns, Germs And Steel | Jared Diamond
post image
Pickpick

Although first published in 1997, I've never got to read this one. It also includes a postface to the 2003 edition. The book revolves around the idea that historical progress, development and domination of different populations over others was fueled by their geography and not their biology.

'Over the past 13,000 years the predominant trend in human society has been the replacement of smaller, less complex units by larger, more complex ones.'

51 likes1 stack add
blurb
Therewillbebooks
Before the Revolution | Daniel K. Richter
post image

Happy Thanksgiving everybody!

IuliaC Happy Thanksgiving! 1y
Ruthiella Happy Thanksgiving to you! 🦃🙏 1y
68 likes2 comments
review
Cosmos_Moon
Guns, Germs and Steel | Diamond, Jared
post image
Mehso-so

I feel like this was a (self inflicted) required reading to get through. Thank goodness for audiobooks and a 30 minute commute. This book provides good histories of where people came from and how we are stratified in society today, and argues against some evolutionists racist explanations. In the academic sense, this book is fantastic, however as he does in Collapse, Diamond beats a dead horse at times. Not always captivating and entertaining.

LitStephanie I didn't like this one either. I am often dissatisfied with Diamond's conclusions as it seems to me he cherry picks data. 1y
35 likes1 comment
review
Yahui07
post image
Pickpick

This book surprised me because I didn‘t realize that it would go back to the time of St Patrick which I enjoyed very much. However it did start slow but I learned more about Ireland/ Irish.

kspenmoll Me too- learned so much when I read it. 2y
Yahui07 @kspenmoll Nice to meet like minded friend! 2y
6 likes2 comments
review
iread2much
post image
Panpan

My dear friend gave this to me, and while I learned a lot about how some Christians might view the Jewish contributions to early western culture, I didn‘t learn a lot about what the Jewish people accomplished. I personally found the writing style irritating, I don‘t like when an author tells me to do things, and this books really needs citations.
1/5 stars. Easy to read, but not very informative

ManyWordsLater I‘m so interested in your take on this book! Can you explain more? 2y
iread2much @ManyWordsLater certainly! I‘m not sure which part you are most interested in, so I‘ll make some small comments and will respond to any comments you would like 😊 the authors makes a lot of statements that he doesn‘t support with evidence, like that Jewish people were the first people to believe that they shouldn‘t follow tradition blindly. I could believe that, if he provided more evidence about other ancient people and their beliefs. (edited) 2y
iread2much @ManyWordsLater I also found that his argument that because the Jewish people started to worship one god above other others, they were able to start the concept of history as we know it, with a future. I don‘t know enough about ancient people to disagree with this, but I also don‘t know if I can agree with it. He also acknowledged that stories in the Old Testament were similar to other ancient gods, but not the Jesus story 2y
16 likes3 comments
review
Hooked_on_books
Guns, Germs and Steel | Diamond, Jared
post image
Pickpick

I read about half this book eons ago then set it aside and never got back to it. I remember really enjoying it (I was in school at the time, so that‘s probably why it got shelved), so I‘m glad I finally went back and finished it. Diamond lays out how differences in locations most likely led to differences in how societies moved through time, rather than inherent racial (racist) differences. 👇🏼

Hooked_on_books Tucked inside, I found this letter from my aunt in 1999 (she died in her 90s within 6 months of writing it), so this book is a time capsule! According to her letter, I was recommending books even then! 2y
vivastory I love everything about this review! 2y
51 likes1 stack add2 comments