Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Ravine
The Ravine: A Family, a Photograph, a Holocaust Massacre Revealed | Wendy Lower
5 posts | 6 read | 12 to read
A single photographan exceptionally rare action shot documenting the horrific final moment of the murder of a familydrives a riveting process of discovery for a gifted Holocaust scholar In 2009, the acclaimed author of Hitlers Furies was shown a photograph just brought to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. The documentation of the Holocaust is vast, but there are virtually no images of a Jewish family at the actual moment of murder, in this case by German officials and Ukrainian collaborators. A Ukrainian shooters rifle is inches from a woman's head, obscured in a cloud of smoke. She is bending forward, holding the hand of a barefooted little boy. Andonly one of the shocking revelations of Wendy Lowers brilliant ten-year investigation of this imagethe shins of another child, slipping from the womans lap. Wendy Lowers forensic and archival detective workin Ukraine, Germany, Slovakia, Israel, and the United Statesrecovers astonishing layers of detail concerning the open-air massacres in Ukraine. The identities of mother and children, of the killersand, remarkably, of the Slovakian photographer who openly took the image, as a secret act of resistanceare dramatically uncovered. Finally, in the hands of this brilliant exceptional scholar, a single image unlocks a new understanding of the place of the family unit in the ideology of Nazi genocide.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
ncsufoxes
post image
Pickpick

The book is based on a photograph brought to the Holocaust Museum in DC. There were so many important & sad points made throughout the book. There are so many people & families that were murdered that historians feel that they still don‘t have the full story. That there has been so much whitewashing & pushback on researchers. Making it difficult to access archives or digger further into the past. My grandmothers family left Poland in the early

ncsufoxes 1900s. My grandmother was born in the US but her older sister was born in Poland. My mom doesn‘t even know what village they came from. We think they possibly were somewhere near what is now Ukraine. They were Catholic & we understand that something must have prompted them to leave Poland. My mom said her grandparents never spoke English & they never discussed where they were from. I am always trying to find more answers to this puzzle. 1mo
TheBookHippie I hope you find answers. This book was so good. 1mo
ncsufoxes @TheBookHippie my mom has decided to take a genealogy class to see what she can learn. I‘ve also suggested that she get a copy of her mom‘s birth certificate to see if it lists where her parents were born. Her dad is from Ireland & she had requested a copy of his birth certificate from Ireland (her, my sisters & I are working on our dual citizenship). She knows she has family in Ireland but she wonders if anyone survived in Poland. 1mo
TheBookHippie @ncsufoxes hardly any Jewish people did, I heard Catholics were lost in big numbers too -but I can‘t recollect if was from hiding Jews or just resisting in general, or both. It will be interesting what she learns. 1mo
AnnCrystal 💝 Ancestry research is a rewarding experience 🫂💝. 1mo
26 likes5 comments
quote
kspenmoll
post image

The author explains her commitment to unpacking the found photograph detailing the murder (at first glance) of a young boy & a woman,both Jewish in Miropol, Ukraine, 10/13/1941. @Amiable Thank you so much for reviewing this! Once I read your review I knew i had to read it. #blameitonlitsy #antifabookclub #readingispolitical #overcomingevilempires

Suet624 Bless you for reading this. 4mo
Amiable It‘s amazing how she was able to track down so many details, isn‘t it ? 4mo
Chrissyreadit I definitely want to read this. 3mo
54 likes2 stack adds3 comments
quote
kspenmoll
post image

In 2009,the author was searching in the archives of the US Holocaust Memorial Museum for Nazi documentation that might result in the prosecution of the notorious Bernhard Frank,(Himmler protege)known to be alive in Germany.Two Prague journalists interrupted her to show her this photograph taken on 10/13/1941, in Miropol,Ukraine.This find prompted her to undertake a quest to answer the questions this photograph seemed to be asking of her.

dabbe 💔 4mo
Butterfinger It just breaks your soul. 4mo
AnnCrystal 😢🙏🏼. 4mo
52 likes3 stack adds3 comments
review
Amiable
post image
Pickpick

In 2009, historian Wendy Lower discovered this photo in the US Holocaust Memorial Museum. It depicts the actual moment of the murder of a Jewish family in 1941. Over a 10-year period, Lower conducted extensive research to identify the location and date of the mass executions, the German and Ukrainian soldiers who pulled the triggers, the Slovakian photographer who snapped the photo —and the identities of the woman and her children. #antifabookclub

kspenmoll I have this - somewhere so must find it after your review! I have been mercilessly culling my bookshelves for our local library sale, so it‘s sure to turn up! 4mo
Amiable @kspenmoll I am in awe of Lower‘s research skills! 4mo
See All 16 Comments
Butterfinger There are no words. 4mo
Chrissyreadit This must have been an incredible and intense research effort. Thank you so much for sharing this. We are already complicit in innocent people disappearing today as a nation and I can only hope we do not see this also. 4mo
AmyG 😥 4mo
sarahbarnes 💔💔💔 4mo
Susanita Horrific 4mo
dabbe I literally couldn't breathe while reading this. 😮‍💨😤😪 4mo
TheBookHippie I know the story. Haven‘t read the book. Just ordered it. 4mo
Suet624 And as Trump sends people to camps, who can guarantee that things like this won‘t happen 4mo
TheBookHippie @Suet624 I suspect they will. 4mo
Deblovestoread The same ones who don't care about camps in America also said Never Forget. The disconnect is unreal. I'll be ordering the book as well. 4mo
CBee This picture made me gasp. I‘ll be looking for this book as well 💔 4mo
Leftcoastzen I have it on the TBR , moving it up! 4mo
AnnCrystal
...Horrifying...no words 😢🙏🏼...
4mo
54 likes2 stack adds16 comments