Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Inevitable Gift Shop
The Inevitable Gift Shop | Will Eaves
11 posts | 4 read | 5 to read
Its like a conversation with an extraordinarily wise friend: surprising, tender, funny and profound.
Michelle de Kretser
Subtitled A memoir by other means, The Inevitable Gift Shop lassoes consciousness, memory, desire, literature, illness, flora and fauna, problems with tortoises and cable ties, and brings them back home in double file, as prose and poetry. This is now, or as good as. / We should welcome it. / There should be hats.
Penetratingly clever and often quite moving and extremely charming, border-crossing uncategorisable writing ... theres something holistic about it, in the way it enacts the absolute continuity between inner and outer life, what we feel what we think what we do.
Patrick McGuinness
It takes itself apart and puts itself back together again as it goes along like a literary Transformer, morphing from prose to poetry, literary criticism to history, every new shape a brilliant incarnation ... This is an odd book, no question, one I back to last.
Ian Duhig
Heartbreaking and hilarious.
Ian Sansom
If there were rules to writing which there arent, probably this book is rewriting them Eaves is cutting an entirely new path, machete in hand, through bush, briar and jungle into uncharted artistic territory Its a book that demands to be read and re-read and then re-read again; both front to back, back to front, and in all other manner of combinations.
Nothingintherulebook.com
its a mixture of autobiographical anecdotes, poetry, micro-narratives, literary criticism and philosophical musings. In grouping these styles of writing within distinct sections, the book takes on a remarkable fluidity where different parts comment upon each other and a deeper, more complex understanding of a whole life is imaginatively constructed.
The title is a reference to a guides remark of a tourist site in Iceland that there is an inevitable gift shop. For me, this image took on significance throughout suggesting that parts of our lives are parcelled up and offered up, but they serve only as imitations of the real thing an absolutely fascinating, cerebral and original book that raised so many questions for me not just about the content of what I was reading but how I was reading it.
Lonesomereader.com
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
blurb
batsy
post image

Yesterday's #bookmail was an edition of "Shawn's Bail is My Gain". The wonderful @shawnmooney did not enjoy this at all and saw it on my TBR and passed it along. ? Here's hoping I don't bail. ?

LeahBergen Nice! 👏🏻👏🏻 7y
37 likes1 comment
review
shawnmooney
post image
Bailedbailed

How infuriating for me and embarrassing for the publisher that such pedantic garbage ever found its way into book form.

Cinfhen Ouch! Well at least a spot just opened up on your Biblio-dance card!!! 😜 7y
TobeyTheScavengerMonk But how do you really feel? 7y
See All 7 Comments
shawnmooney @Cinfhen Yes, and that spot shall go to to the much-anticipated novel that won the award in memory of your beloved friend! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ 7y
Cinfhen Wooohoo!!! I hope you love it 😍 7y
CouronneDhiver Haha! Great review. 😂😂 7y
41 likes7 comments
review
saresmoore
post image
Panpan

I tried with this one, I really did. In fact, I'm not calling it a bail because I read so much of it. There were two brief passages that I found amusing and a handful that were thought-provoking, but ultimately Eaves does too much literary name dropping & pedantic philosophizing and not enough good storytelling or even musing. He writes, "Criticism ought to be succinct and simple and it is no easy task to be either." Clearly.

saresmoore @LectricSheep @bookhoarder513 @shelf-improvement @shawnmooney So, obviously this book wasn't my cuppa tea, but I'd still love to hear your thoughts & discuss if you continue reading! 7y
shawnmooney @LectricSheep @bookhoarder513 @saresmoore @shelf-improvement Yeah I am totally hating it too so even though I was the one who suggested the buddy read, I will probably bail, as well. I am going to (hate-)read a few more pages before deciding. Sorry! 7y
Cinfhen Sorry you all hated it ! 7y
See All 11 Comments
bookhoarder513 I am so glad I am not the only one not enjoying this. I thought I was missing something. I will probably try a bit more, but not much. Love the term (hate)read. 😁 @shawnmooney @LectricSheep @saresmoore @shelf-improvement 7y
shelf-improvement I read about half of it and there are some passages I like, but I'm not feeling the overall piece. 😟 7y
saresmoore @bookhoarder513 @shelf-improvement @shawnmooney Glad we all tried, anyway. We can save other Litsy folks from reading it! (edited) 7y
shelf-improvement By the way, does anyone know if CB Editions is considered a micropress? It seems it might be just the one guy and I might be able to cross that off my Read Harder checklist. @saresmoore @shawnmooney @bookhoarder513 @LectricSheep 7y
saresmoore @shelf-improvement Yes, definitely a micropress! Great point. 7y
shelf-improvement @saresmoore woo hoo! I don't have to find another book to fulfill that category. 🙆 7y
Hobbinol Too bad❗️ 7y
saresmoore @Hobbinol It's okay. My current read is making up for it. 7y
50 likes11 comments
quote
shelf-improvement
post image

"Characters, for the novelist, are a means of doing the impossible: observing ourselves from the outside." #BuddyRead @shawnmooney @saresmoore @LectricSheep @bookhoarder513

TobeyTheScavengerMonk Hey @Maggany the Howard Jacobson quote you posted reminded me of this excellence I say earlier today. 7y
29 likes1 comment
quote
saresmoore
post image

Is anyone else reminded of Marshall McLuhan (the medium is the message, we shape our tools and thereafter our tools shape us) here?

andrew61 The only thing I know about Marshall is that he appeared in Annie Hall (i think!) 7y
saresmoore @andrew61 That wouldn't surprise me! My husband is a long-time McLuhan fan, so we have a few of his quirky books. Pretty fascinating, actually, in light of his influence on postmodern thought. 7y
51 likes3 comments
quote
saresmoore
post image

This just made me laugh out loud. For some reason, people come to me frequently with their bizarre, yet painfully boring dreams for an interpretation. My response is almost invariably: "Ah, interesting. And how did that make you FEEL?"

I agree with Eaves here, of course. The subconscious is pretty subjective.

Kalalalatja I can relate to this so much! 😂 7y
saresmoore @Kalalalatja Even the scary flower vase? Haha! 7y
Kalalalatja More the friends asking me to analyse their dreams part 😂 but everyone got their monsters 😄 7y
See All 13 Comments
LeahBergen "So, I was having this dream? And I had to do a Litsy post and couldn't find the right book? Or where to photograph it?" ?? 7y
LeahBergen Am I boring you? 7y
saresmoore @LeahBergen Bahahaha! And how did that make you feel, Leah?? Oh goodness. I can actually imagine having that dream. 7y
Moray_Reads Almost all my dreams are about work. My subconscious is boring, that's why it needs a steady diet of books 7y
saresmoore @Moray_Reads Hahaha! That is a great conclusion. Even though work involves a lot of books for you, doesn't it? 7y
Suet624 I dreamt recently that I was reading a book in three parts. I had to find the parts in the bedroom. What the heck does that mean? My feeling? Confusion and concern. Hmmm...actually, okay, never mind. I think I know what that dream was about. 7y
saresmoore @Suet624 Ah, the overwhelmed-by-too-many-books dream. Or is it more complex? A divided heart? Maybe you're supposed to start writing a book about your life! 🙂 7y
shawnmooney Again, I don't think Eaves is saying a whole lot that's particularly interesting. I think he likes the sound of his own voice. I can't imagine that somebody narrating a stupid dream full of their own emotional reactions to it would make it any more interesting for me to listen to! :-) 7y
saresmoore @shawnmooney Ahahahaha! No, it wouldn't. I really want to glean some deep wisdom or humor from it, but so far, it reads like a particularly pretentious personal journal with lots of name dropping. 🤔 7y
Suet624 I believe you're spot on with my dream analysis. It's all of that. 7y
60 likes13 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

The topic—how important liking a character is or should be to liking a book—is of great interest to me, and I suspect to many of us. But I must admit I'm not wowed by Eaves's musings here: a little too abstruse and condescending for my liking. That may be another way of saying his deep insights went right over my country bumpkin head. What do others think?

MrsMalaprop Fascinating. In my book club (of 20 years!) I've heard members say they didn't like a book because the characters are unlikeable. Some of the best books have characters that I didn't like much. The Slap is a case in point. The figurative mirror as an explanation is interesting, but a bit simplistic. I wonder about being challenged by diversity: the more open and accepting you are, the more you welcome the opportunity to understand difference. 🤔 7y
BkClubCare Fun stuff. I know that I am most challenged by characters that reflect something specific abt myself I don't like and being aware of it helps but always uncomfortable. 7y
See All 23 Comments
merelybookish Hmmm...interesting. I think reading to relate is considered an unsophisticated way of reading. It's something that is encouraged for kids, though. It's what the we need diverse books is about - that all kinds of kids need books that they can relate to, to see themselves represented. The metaphor used is books as mirrors. BUT it should also be a window, a means to learn about others, a tool to develop empathy. And imagination. 7y
merelybookish Also it tends to be a gendered term. Women are more often accused of reading to relate. Female characters are more often dismissed as unlikable. Or it comes up as a problem more with women writers. Claire Messud has discussed this. Humber Humbert is a truly unlikable character, for example. No one seems to Lolita on that basis. 7y
Lesliereads What about reading to relate to another's humanity? 7y
merelybookish Sorry! One more thought. (This is a topic I've spent some time on...) As a teacher, I used to hate it when students would respond to a book by saying, "I could relate" because it shut down conversation. It made the book known and easy to understand somehow. There was no need for analysis. So to go back to the quote, there is something emotional about it. 7y
shawnmooney Great comments everyone!

@MrsMalaprop @BkClubCare @merelybookish @Lesliereads
To the degree that I understand his text (to the degree it makes sense?) Eaves seems to be complicating the standard psychological concept of projection.
7y
shawnmooney He is saying (is he not) that if you don't like a literary character that is NOT because that character reminds you of a disowned part of your own self (the accepted definition of projection, with which some of you are agreeing). 7y
shawnmooney Rather, he is saying that your dislike stems from your guilt at having treated someone like that unkindly, cruelly, in real life. Isn't he? Even putting aside the high-falutin' way he expresses this idea, it just doesn't ring true for me. I shall stand, waiting for correction and enlightenment. :) 7y
LectricSheep @shawnmooney Or even just your *potential* to treat someone else poorly (with "contempt," as he says). You might not actually admit to feeling contempt for this character if they were real, but in literature there are way fewer social safety nets in place to keep you from admitting how you really feel-- if only to yourself. 7y
BkClubCare @shawnmooney - I don't disagree with your take. I think my comment was more what thoughts were churned up in the wake. For books that I most dislike and analyze why, I don't like the feelings I shine that spotlight on. And usually are not what others also dislike abt a book. So maybe my comment isn't quite relevant to this text... I don't think I've confronted the guilt component myself. (edited) 7y
BkClubCare But fun stuff to think about when emotions not in play. 7y
shawnmooney @BkClubCare My point is, your comments as well as the other other Litsy folks', strike me as exponentially more interesting and relevant that what he wrote. 💜💜 7y
saresmoore Shawn, if you're a country bumpkin, then I'm a Neanderthal! I didn't much care for this one, as it just seemed like the thesis (if there is one) didn't match the conclusion, but I really appreciate the discussion it sparked here! 7y
shelf-improvement I do think people struggle with the distinction between liking and understanding, not just in fiction but in real life: it's important to understand the point of view of people who are your political opposite in order to reach a compromise, but that doesn't​ mean approving or endorsing. That being said, I disagree that wanting to like a character necessarily means wanting your world view trumpeted back to you. 7y
shelf-improvement Or even that it's reaching some Freudian sense of guilt or shame. 7y
ValerieAndBooks Great discussion here. If such a book has nothing else going for it then I think I'd be inclined to blame my dislike on the characters. But if the author holds my interest regardless (great writing or plot or whatever) then I like it even if it's filled with unlikeable characters. 7y
shelf-improvement I also think it's a stretch to apply that La Rochefoucauld quote to the start of his thought. It suggests we are harming characters we don't like, doesn't it? Which doesn't make sense to me. Unless he's suggesting the unliked character reminds us of real-life people we feel guilty for harming? 7y
shelf-improvement For me personally, I can deal with unlikable characters as long as I feel like I understand why they behave in unlikable ways. Walter White comes to mind, though not a literary character. 7y
shawnmooney @shelf-improvement Thank you! I'm glad I'm not the only one who sensed that disjuncture. :-) 7y
shawnmooney Usually, I don't care so much about how likable a character is: for me, the make-or-break measure is how much I care about or at least am interested in the character. I do tend to bail when I find the protagonist to be really boring in some offputting way; I suppose that could be interpreted as finding their character unlikable. And while I didn't bail on it, I did loathe the old woman at the center of Szabo's The Door - so sometimes.... (edited) 7y
shawnmooney ...unlikeability trumps pretty much everything else! That is rare, in my reading experience, though. (edited) 7y
31 likes2 stack adds23 comments
blurb
bookhoarder513
post image

Look what came today! 😊 is the buddy read still on? @shawnmooney I don't remember who else was joining in.

shawnmooney It is! I am planning to start in today too. Here are the other peeps: @Lindy @LectricSheep @bookhoarder513 @saresmoore @shelf-improvement 7y
shawnmooney @lindy since you can't read it yet but plan to later, do you want to be tagged in these posts, or not? 7y
Lindy @shawnmooney No, thank you. Don't tag me, but I will scroll to look for your posts later, once I read it. 😊 7y
23 likes3 comments
blurb
shelf-improvement
post image

Bookmail, all the way from London for the @shawnmooney -organized buddy read.

blurb
shawnmooney
post image

Looking forward to the May buddy-read of this one!

shawnmooney @Lindy @LectricSheep @bookhoarder513 @saresmoore @shelf-improvement Hello lovely Litsy people, just wanting to doublecheck that we are all on track for buddy reading this in May? I don't think there's any time sensitivity whatsoever, so if anybody would like to postpone this, let us know. Otherwise, let's dive in on May 1st! :-) 7y
LectricSheep Mine just got here last week! I'm excited! May 1 is good for me! 👍🏻 7y
saresmoore Yay! May 1 sounds great! 7y
See All 6 Comments
shelf-improvement Yes, thanks for the reminder!! 7y
Lindy According to my local library, this title doesn't yet have rights in North America. I will wait until later to read it, but I look forward to your posts about it. 7y
bookhoarder513 I found it on Amazon but had to order now to get it by May 2. I'm in the US. 7y
38 likes6 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

Somebody on Twitter – I have no idea who – posted this crudely photographed excerpt from this book of prose, prose poems, and poetry out of the UK today. Then I googled more about the book and the writer; am I the only one who absolutely needs to read this as soon as possible?

saresmoore ?(predictably) The description of a tortoise as "amphibian" bothered me a little, but I'll chalk it up to poetic license. ? (edited) 7y
shawnmooney @saresmoore Thank you for teaching me a little bit of biology. I think we can give poets a pass on such matters? :-) if you go to this publisher page, underneath the ISBN number, you can click on a link to a longer PDF excerpt: http://www.cbeditions.com/eaves2.html. If you are still intrigued, why don't we both track down a copy and do a buddy read in, say, May? It's a short little book. I'll probably order mine from Book Depository. 7y
shawnmooney Maybe others will join in… 7y
See All 13 Comments
saresmoore He had me at "There should be hats". I'm definitely in for a buddy read. 7y
shawnmooney Maybe @shelf-improvement and @LectricSheep will join @saresmoore and I in this May 2017 buddy read? 7y
LectricSheep I'm in! 7y
shelf-improvement Ooh, I'd do that! 7y
shawnmooney @bookhoarder513 After you've read all these comments, maybe you will decide to join us too? :-) 7y
shawnmooney And I can't help extending a special invitation to @Lindy since she's such a poetry buff, and will probably fall over when she hears I'm going to read a book that includes copious amounts of poetry… :-) 7y
bookhoarder513 @shawnmooney I'm in! Thank you! 7y
Lindy @shawnmooney I've just placed a suggestion to my public library that it be purchased. Meanwhile, o Caledonia is here! 7y
38 likes5 stack adds13 comments