Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Fear For Miss Betony
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
21 posts | 7 read | 3 to read
Former governess Emma Betony is living in quiet and boring retirement when two unexpected letters arrive. The first is a lonely hearts magazine, with an entry ("Lonely Batchelor, age 49, good health, comfortable income, seeks friendship of unattached lady with view to matrimony") highlighted by the anonymous sender. The second is an appeal for help from a former student. Grace Aram is running Makeways, a struggling boarding school for girls, newly relocated to a site of former nursing home in Dorset. Grace isn't interested in Miss Betony's teaching skills-she wants a trusted friend to help identify the culprit behind a series of troubling events. Two nursing patients have remained at Makeways and one appears to be the victim of a poisoner. It is not clear who could be responsible for the ongoing trickle of arsenic found in Miss Thurloe's drinks- the new abrasive doctor, the pragmatic nurse, the nervous teaching staff or the high-strung students. During her investigations, Miss Betony uncovers an overwhelming sense of fear on the part of Makeways' inhabitants, and clues that lead to the Great Ambrosio, a charismatic fortune-teller, who seems to have an undue influence on various teachers, students - and Miss Thurloe. First published in 1941, Fear and Miss Betony marks the final appearance of Chief Inspector Dan Pardoe-but it is Miss Betony herself who fights through fear and solves the case. Contemporary critics proclaimed the book an instant classic, with an ingenious plot.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
quote
charl08
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers

Emma was sensitive about books. She believed that their arrangement on a shelf should accord with their temperaments and characters, and that, as in human relationships only mutual irritation was induced by stressing incompatibility. So what was The Mistress of Shenstone doing next to Commercial Book- Keeping for the Student, and The Tailor of Gloucester.... shoulder to shoulder with Mr. Pendlebury's excellent Arithmetic?

37 likes1 stack add
review
batsy
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image
Pickpick

I enjoyed this quite a bit & it reminded me of Dorothy Sayers' Gaudy Night: the same cloistered environment of women & girls in close quarters & the same kind of simmering psychological motivations for the murder. Bowers' writing is quite delightful; it might seem over-written at first as the pace is slow, but it picks up nicely & provides so many interesting insights into the social & material conditions of the time. #GoldenAgeCrimeClub @Mitch

Cathythoughts Lovely review ❤️ 10mo
BarbaraBB Great review an oh that cover 🥰 10mo
batsy @Cathythoughts Thanks, Cathy 😘 10mo
See All 16 Comments
batsy @BarbaraBB Yes, the other titles also have cute covers ❤️ 10mo
batsy One for the annals of #spinsterlit I must add! 10mo
vivastory I read my first Dorothy Sayers last month. Loved it! 10mo
batsy @vivastory Ooh, which one? 10mo
vivastory @batsy Murder Must Advertise. While reading it I had the impression that it was a post WW-II novel. I was a bit shocked to find that it was pre-war once I checked. There were entire passages about office politics & the dominance of capitalism that could easily be moved into a contemporary novel. I thought it was brilliant how in the end the financial aspects that Sayer's portrays ties into the mystery itself without feeling manipulative. 10mo
batsy @vivastory MMA is one of my faves! Great point about the depiction of the workplace and how the logic of capitalism operates; it struck me when I read it, too, but it was many years ago and your comments are prompting me to revisit it soon 🙂 10mo
vivastory Do you have any particular favorites by Sayers? I'm uncertain where to go next. 10mo
batsy @vivastory I'm a big fan of all four books where Harriet Vane appears (Strong Poison, Have His Carcase, Gaudy Night, and Busman's Honeymoon). Out of the standalone Wimsey ones I've only read MMA, Whose Body (the first one, interesting but also kind of flawed) and The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club, which was a lot of fun as I remember! 10mo
vivastory Thanks so much for your detailed response! Noting the recommendations. I think I will make Gaudy Night my next one as I have seen it pop up previously & it will be interesting to read about a different character than Wimsey. 10mo
vivastory I still need to read Jospehine Tey. I know she was writing around the same time as Christie & Sayers & is generally considered one of the best. 10mo
batsy @vivastory Josephine Tey has some good ones. The Daughter of Time is really excellent imo. We read The Franchise Affair for #GoldenAgeCrimeClub recently; a reread for me but the mystery stands up after all this time. I also loved Miss Pym Disposes and Brat Farrar but they do come with some regressive social views. They way she builds atmosphere is fantastic, though. And she's a bit ruthless with her characters so it's never too "cosy" or cute. 10mo
vivastory I have heard positive things about both Daughter of Time & Ms Pym. Your comment about her being ruthless with her characters has me even more intrigued as it puts me in mind of Muriel Spark's treatment of her characters in some of her novels. 9mo
batsy @vivastory I need to read more Spark for sure! I've only read the tagged but it was so good 9mo
85 likes16 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

After many delays look what finally arrived. Better late than never I suppose. Too late for the discussion but I‘ll still read it. @Mitch #Goldenagecrimeclub

Ruthiella You can chime in still! I hope you like it. 😃 10mo
Cuilin @Ruthiella thanks, did you like it? 10mo
Mitch Please just jump in whenever you can. Xxx 10mo
Ruthiella I did like it. It just took me a while to adjust to the writing style. 10mo
51 likes4 comments
review
kwmg40
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image
Pickpick

I enjoyed this Golden Age mystery about a retired governess who helps a former pupil by investigating mysterious events at a combination nursing home and boarding school. The story was creepy and suspenseful but also had touches of humour, and the characters were great.

Thanks to @Mitch for hosting this group read as part of the #goldenagecrimeclub!

#BookSpinBingo @TheAromaofBooks
#192025 #1941 @Librarybelle

Librarybelle I‘m looking forward to this one - have not had a chance to start it yet! 10mo
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! 10mo
36 likes2 comments
review
lauraisntwilder
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image
Pickpick

It was killing me, waiting to see what was written on that paper Emma stole at her reading! I audibly gasped toward the end -- did NOT expect to come back to the pet shop, let alone what had happened there. I'm glad I read this one and would like to read more Bowers, but maybe editions with larger type? The type in this book seemed tiny to me. #goldenagecrimeclub

blurb
Aimeesue
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

I‘m not sure why this edition has a slightly different title, but I like the cover. Ambrosio‘s got quite the hairdo.
#GoldenAgeCrimeClub

jlhammar I, too, was curious about that title change/variation! 10mo
quietjenn Not exactly the handsomest man ever 😅 10mo
26 likes2 comments
review
jlhammar
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image
Pickpick

Good mystery! Really glad this was a pick for #GoldenAgeCrimeClub as Bowers was not on my radar. Loved our amateur sleuth, Miss Emma Betony, and the nursing home/boarding school setting. I also appreciated the humor and liked her “fair play” style, presenting all of the clues for the reader to work out.

blurb
Mitch
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

There were also lots of funny bits in this novel - some chuckles, some great older characters and some novel bizarre parental choices! Overall thoughts, fractions, things we‘ve missed?
#goldenagecrimeclub

Ruthiella Overall it was rather complicated, I thought. Like, if the murderer had thought a little harder, there would have been an easier way to go about it? 🤔 10mo
jlhammar The humor was my favorite part. First, the fact that Toplady residence was called a “Home for Decayed Gentlewomen“ was pretty great. That Emma, a retired teacher, admits to finding children rather odious. That “cherishing them was simply a measure of self-preservation...a colossal game of let's pretend.“ Just lots of fun bits like that. I think my favorite part of the mystery though was in Chapter XI when Emma makes her list of observations. 10mo
quietjenn I agree with @Ruthiella, in that it seems overly-complicated when you stand back from it. Yet, I totally enjoyed it and it didn't make me roll my eyes, the way some mysteries can. 😂 And like @jlhammar I loved the humor that was woven throughout. And I just appreciated Miss Betony in general - and am glad that the policeman (who I think are at the center of Bowers other mysteries) admire and respect her too! 10mo
See All 7 Comments
Ruthiella @quietjenn Yes! Props to the cops who appreciated Miss Betony and her deductions ! At that point, the tension was so heightened, it was a relief to know they were on her side. 10mo
kwmg40 I too liked the humour and I also enjoyed seeing the very different personalities of all the staff members. 10mo
batsy Yes @jlhammar I loved that line. She had another one about the class differences and how the bourgeoisie view the working class folks like herself, and went on to characterise the middle-class as having "small incomes, smaller brains, and smallest talents" and their instinct for survival & reproducing their class alliances. She didn't hold back in that brief paragraph which really was some astute commentary. 10mo
Mitch @jlhammar 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 10mo
38 likes7 comments
blurb
Mitch
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

The fortune teller was a fab character - one of the only men in the book and we see him briefly. Whilst lots of the mystery tropes are in this book - his character seems quite unusual! It felt very different from a Christy or Sayers novel……
#goldenagecrimeclub

Ruthiella I found him quite creepy. 😱 10mo
Mitch @Ruthiella me too! Those scenes were quite tense … 10mo
jlhammar The Great Ambrosio, the master, the wizard of Bugle 😂 - yes, quite the creepy character! That whole scene when Miss Betony visits him was a good one. And when she glances back and catches him “looking at her with an expression of violent distaste on his face“ as she was leaving - yikes! 10mo
See All 7 Comments
quietjenn @jlhammar although I'm honestly not sure what to make of Ambrosio overall, I did really love that scene! 10mo
kspenmoll Totally mesmerizing & creepy!A great character. 10mo
kwmg40 I liked Ambrosio as a character and found him creepy but did sense that he was a conman. 10mo
batsy Agreed, he was creepy! And a red flag character from the start. This characterisation of Ambrosio and the bits involving him reminded me a tiny bit of Christie's The Mysterious Mr. Quin short story collection. 10mo
24 likes7 comments
blurb
Mitch
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

The war felt like it had a strong presence in this book - it was lingering in the background in terms of the older women‘s histories and the current (1941) situation of WW2. I wonder how it was writing fiction during war time. ……..
#goldenagecrimeclub

Ruthiella It must have been difficult to write contemporary works during the war. In retrospect, we know when and how it ended, but authors didn‘t have that knowledge. 10mo
Mitch @Ruthiella I dont think I‘ve really thought about that a lot until recently. But you‘re so right - what did it feel like when the thought of a German occupation was still a reality. 10mo
Mitch Having read a few books now around this time period they seem to fall into two categories- ignore it and use fiction as an escape or face it head on. This seems to be in the middle…. 10mo
See All 7 Comments
jlhammar Yes, good points about WWII lingering in the background and this seeming to be in the middle of the usual categories (comfort/escape or war-focused). I think there was some remembering back to WWI in the beginning too, to around the time when Grace was her student. Makes me think about how people like fortune tellers and mediums took advantage of all the loss and vulnerability following WWI. This great Kate Summerscale book explored that a bit 10mo
quietjenn It actually didn't feel like that to me, but maybe because I'm more accustomed to books that, like @Mitch said, either have it at the center of the story or don't mention it at all. 10mo
batsy Yes, it wasn't overt but I wonder if it was lingering in the background in the sense of the shifting sense of social and gender hierarchies and how it shaped women's desires and ambitions, especially in relation to the ending. Great point @jlhammar about how fortune tellers would have exploited that uncertainty at the time. Thanks for the book rec, I've had this by her on the TBR for far too long 10mo
Mitch @jlhammar that‘s a fab reference- thanks for reminding me - great book 10mo
26 likes7 comments
blurb
Mitch
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

I loved the first sentence “ At the age of 61 Emma Betony in a kindly light looked ten years younger” ….. I‘m always on the look out for kindly light! What did you think of our sleuth?

#goldenagecrimeclub

Ruthiella I quite liked her. 👍 She was intelligent, enterprising and courageous. 10mo
Mitch I liked her humble roots (like the author) and the fact she did have to factor in money in her decision making, she needed to count the pennies - which made her feel real to me. 10mo
jlhammar Emma Betony was pretty great as far as sleuths go. Very perceptive and no nonsense! I also liked that about her @Mitch - loved the end when she shares her modest plans/dreams and says “I'm too old to be rich now. I wouldn't know what to do.“ 10mo
See All 10 Comments
Ruthiella @jlhammar Totally agree about the end. It was just perfect, the modesty and self-awareness. 👌 10mo
lauraisntwilder I liked her a lot. I emjoyed her reluctance -- and then her surprise at how easy it was to get answers. 10mo
quietjenn I thought she was great! Tons of personality, good sense of humor, very down-to-earth, observant, and she definitely knows who she is. Totally agree with what others have said here. 10mo
kspenmoll I too enjoyed her character- agree with all that is said here. 10mo
kwmg40 Like the others who commented earlier, I liked the main character very much. Emma is a very “ordinary“ person but with good perception, courage and empathy. 10mo
batsy Agree with all of the comments here. She grabs your attention from the start with her opinions and insight, very little with which I disagreed with. Resourceful, smart, and definitely with an eye for closing in on the right details. 10mo
Mitch I‘d really like to have more adventures with her. She‘s just so nice! 10mo
25 likes10 comments
blurb
Mitch
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

#goldenagecrimeclub

What did you think of the setting? A school / nursing home with sooo many staff and very few residents!

Ruthiella It seemed an odd sort of school in a building maybe unsuitable for a girls boarding school…but then the solution to the mystery goes a way to explain that! 😀 10mo
Mitch @Ruthiella I thought it really weird! But it was wartime and I suppose things worked out in different ways. I was sitting with the oddness as I was reading - didn‘t once assume there was a reason for it! 🤣🤣 10mo
jlhammar Great setting! The somewhat spooky nursing home/boarding school really drew me in. I also found the Makeways school motto pretty hilarious “I make my way in my way.“ 10mo
See All 8 Comments
quietjenn I really love a boarding school OR nursing home setting (thinking of a couple of Christies, a Tey, and a few episodes of Midsomer Murders), but a setting that is both was a bit odd tome. I think that it ultimately worked, but it definitely wasn't what I expected. 10mo
kspenmoll I thought the setting was strange, spooky & mysterious, but fun! 10mo
kwmg40 The combination nursing home and boarding school setting was definitely new to me, but it worked! 10mo
batsy I agree with @kspenmoll ! It is strange but it made for a good creepy and "fun" (since we enjoy mysteries ?) vibe. I'm always up for some "women in close quarters on the edge of anxiety and hysteria" type thing. A bit Gothic! 10mo
Mitch @jlhammar is of loved that as my school motto! I was intrigued by the parents who chose to pay to send their girls there. 👍🏼 10mo
24 likes8 comments
blurb
Mitch
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

#goldenagecrimeclub

Welcome everyone to our fifth buddy read! Posting a few days early as I‘m heading off wild camping tomorrow for a few days!
So let‘s kick off with initial impressions and relationship with the book …..

AmyG I am apologizing….I didn‘t finish this one. Just had alot on my plate this month. Hoping to jump back in next month. 10mo
Ruthiella I‘m only 1/2 way through but I have to say this book is making miss Christie‘s less elaborate writing style. There is SO MUCH DESCRIPTION…I‘m getting a little lost each time, wondering where the plot is…😂 10mo
batsy I'm just starting today but will come back to the discussion when I'm done! 10mo
See All 9 Comments
Mitch @AmyG no need to apologise honey. Talk to you next month x 10mo
jlhammar Wild camping! That sounds pretty cool. Hope you have a wonderful time. I enjoyed this. I'd never heard of Bowers before. Sad that she died so young. I agree with @Ruthiella about the elaborate, descriptive writing. I didn't mind too much once I got into it, but I do prefer Christie's more economical style. 10mo
quietjenn I really liked this! I was also totally unfamiliar with Bowers, but I'd be keen to read more. Although she was a bit wordy, it didn't bother me too much and I thought it was a really good, creative take on the mystery. I didn't figure things out until exactly the moment I think I was supposed to ... 10mo
kspenmoll Chiming in late - initially it felt slow to me “elaborate descriptive writing” as @Ruthiella aptly said, but once I got into the rhythm of the writing I was able to enjoy it. I did not always know what was going on & missed clues but in the end i felt satisfied 10mo
kwmg40 I enjoyed this book. It was a bit of a slow start but once the characters and circumstances were firmly established, the book moved at a good pace and there were surprises for me at the end. 10mo
Mitch @kwmg40 I agree. I think she took a long time to set the scene up and we took some time getting to know Emma before things really started! 10mo
29 likes9 comments
blurb
quietjenn
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

I am, perhaps, not the only one spending time with this book today ...? #goldenagecrimeclub

jlhammar You are not! I‘m about a third of the way through and enjoying it so far. Hope to make some good progress yet this afternoon. 10mo
Tamra I‘m looking forward to your review! 🤞🏾 10mo
batsy Trying to squeeze in as much as I can 😅 10mo
Ruthiella You are not alone! I just finished it! 10mo
52 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
Ruthiella
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

My only goal for this #20in4 Readathon is to start and finish the tagged book by Sunday for the #GoldenAgeCrimeClub! 🤞

I only have access to the ebook via Hoopla on my tablet, my least preferred method (wish I could get it on kindle), but hopefully the book is entrancing enough to make up for it! 😅

Andrew65 Great to have you with us, good luck 😍 10mo
kspenmoll You can do it! 10mo
Ruthiella @Andrew65 Thanks! 🙏 10mo
See All 6 Comments
Ruthiella @kspenmoll Thanks for the encouragement! 😊 10mo
Aimeesue Thank goodness I saw this - I almost forgot! I have the same problem - I can only find it on Hoopla, and I hate reading ebooks on my iPad. Nevertheless, I shall persist! 😄 10mo
Ruthiella @Aimeesue Glad I was able to remind you! Hoopla is awesome for audio, but ebooks, not so much. 🙄 10mo
66 likes6 comments
quote
jlhammar
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

“At the age of sixty-one Emma Betony in a kindly light looked ten years younger.”

Excited to be starting our latest #GoldenAgeCrimeClub selection!

#FirstLineFridays

kspenmoll I just finished. Cannot wait to discuss. 10mo
batsy I just remembered this month's read! Hope to squeeze it in before the end of the month. 10mo
Ruthiella Oopsie Whoopsie! I‘d forgotten this too. I‘m gonna try to read it tonight and tomorrow. 😬 10mo
54 likes3 comments
blurb
lauraisntwilder
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

This is the third book I've read this year with a talking bird in it. I've never heard a bird talk in real life. I mean, I know they don't really talk, but still. Is running across talking birds more common than my own experience leads me to believe??

Clare-Dragonfly I only know one talking bird, an African Grey parrot, but yes, he does really talk! He repeats sounds he‘s heard and genuinely communicates. 10mo
lauraisntwilder @Clare-Dragonfly Okay, that's pretty amazing! 10mo
11 likes2 comments
blurb
kspenmoll
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

Sunday before dinner cocktail. Campari & seltzer w a twist of lime accompanied by Swiss cheese & crackers.#porchlife #goldenagecrimeclub

Tamra This one sounds good - stacked! Beautiful cocktail 😍 10mo
dabbe #porchlife = #thegoodlife 💙💚💙 10mo
60 likes2 stack adds2 comments
blurb
kspenmoll
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

#weeklyforecast
Plan to finish the Moon & the Anchoress
Continue with Out of Bounds
Begin the other two if possible. I have high hopes!

Cinfhen High hopes is good 😊 I think you can 🙌🏻 10mo
46 likes1 comment
blurb
LitsyEvents
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

repost for @Mitch:

Thank you to everyone who is joining in each month for the #goldenagecrimeclub. Each month we‘re reading once book and chatting about it on the last Sunday of the month. Everyone is welcome to join us!
May‘s book takes us into the world of boarding schools!

original post: https://www.litsy.com/web/post/2582343

willaful Did you say boarding schools? My literary catnip! (edited) 11mo
30 likes1 comment
blurb
Mitch
Fear For Miss Betony | Dorothy Bowers
post image

Thank you to everyone who is joining in each month for the #goldenagecrimeclub. Each month we‘re reading once book and chatting about it on the last Sunday of the month. Everyone is welcome to join us!
May‘s book takes us into the world of boarding schools!

Ruthiella Looking forward to this one! Title and author are both new to me. 😀 11mo
batsy @Ruthiella Same! And a boarding school! Can't resist 😆 11mo
Ruthiella @batsy And a boarding school to boot? Excellent. 😅 11mo
erzascarletbookgasm Sounds superb! But I don‘t know where to get a copy 🤷🏻‍♀️ 11mo
57 likes4 comments