Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#THWhite
review
BookWrym
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image
Pickpick

Beautifully written but brutal.

This is a story about grief, coping with loss and finding a reason to go on. It is also a book about TH White and his novel The Goshawk where his ineptitude with nature is revealed and where as usual humans are more brutal than natures killers. Then again it is a book about building a relationship with nature and understanding the darkness and brutal that inhabit the hunt.

Falconry is not for the faint hearted.

batsy Nice review. Agree with your assessment... Beautiful and brutal. 1mo
12 likes1 comment
review
jenniferw88
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image
Pickpick
44 likes2 comments
blurb
mcctrish
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image

#midwintersolace #naturalitsy I LOVED this book. I think it was the cover that grabbed me, then I realized HM wrote this about her grief journey when her father died suddenly. My father had died suddenly and I was ( with my sister) suddenly aware of how much work my father had been doing to support my mom and her declining health ( she eventually was diagnosed with Lewy Body Dementia). Absolutely no falconry aspirations but I got the grief

TheBookHippie ♥️ 3mo
AllDebooks This is still sitting on my bookshelf 📚 3mo
mcctrish @AllDebooks it really is interesting - the parallel story of T. H. White juxtaposed with her adopting and training a goshawk is so good 3mo
See All 6 Comments
quietlycuriouskate Love this book! ❤️ 3mo
AllDebooks @mcctrish I read the T H White book first but never got around to McDonald's book. Maybe this is the prompt to go find it. 🤔 😍 3mo
mcctrish @AllDebooks I‘m now thinking I should hunt up The Goshawk and read it 3mo
41 likes1 stack add6 comments
review
batsy
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image
Pickpick

This was beautiful & sad, with an undercurrent of violence that comes with the territory of "taming" a wild animal. I found it moving in a lot of aspects, & appreciated the biographical aspects of White's life as integral to Macdonald's attempt to work things out within herself. The saddest thing was contemplating these hawks & falcons; do humans have to mess with nature in order to heal themselves? All throughout I just wanted Mabel to be free.

batsy A really stirring read, and a heavy one, not least because it brings to light the vulnerabilities of people in terms of grief, isolation, and depression, but also our worst compulsions in relation to the creatures of the wild. And the cost that these creatures—the natural world itself—bears in order for humans to feel whole again. #TBRTarot @CBee 11mo
Tamra Oh, you touched on why I bailed. 💜 I can‘t bear the thought of wild birds in captivity, unless they have been rehabilitated and cannot be returned. 😔 11mo
squirrelbrain Great review - I have this on my physical TBR shelf and keep meaning to get to it. Your review has bumped it up the list. 11mo
See All 15 Comments
CBee Really fantastic review! 11mo
batsy @Tamra I know, right? It was tough to process that part 😓 11mo
batsy @squirrelbrain Thank you! I'd love to see what you think of it. 11mo
batsy @CBee Thank you! 11mo
jlhammar Wonderful review - glad you enjoyed! I just loved her writing. Good point about wishing Mabel freedom. The relationship between these birds and their handlers seems like it could be one of companionship, respect and affection, but there are definitely ethical considerations. Falconry has quite the history and is fascinating, but one does wonder if it is kind to these wild birds. 11mo
Suet624 A wonderful review as usual. Now I‘m wondering why I wasn‘t more concerned about Mabel. 11mo
batsy @jlhammar Thank you! You bring up a great point that kind of answers @Suet624 - it felt like Macdonald was considerate and careful, which is why you sense that Mabel was in good hands. Yet the underlying question about why this practice exists still troubles me. Her writing was stunning and I appreciate her never taking her eyes off the ugly stuff. 11mo
kspenmoll Such a wonderful review-I just loved this book& learned so much! 11mo
kspenmoll @batsy Well said. The ethical questions the book poses regarding our relationship with the natural world are necessary & disturbing to contemplate. 11mo
batsy @kspenmoll Thank you! I agree, I learned so much as well. I love that the author had could bring so much into the book because of her love of falconry. There's something beautiful and a bit heartbreaking wrt her devotion to Mabel, as well. 11mo
DivineDiana I bought this book for my husband years ago. He did read it, and I have been planning to do the same. Reading your excellent review, I am somewhat hesitant to subject myself to the “worst compulsions”. 11mo
batsy @DivineDiana It's a very good book, but yes it can elicit some complex emotions when you read it. In terms of what it takes to tame a wild bird. The excerpts from T.H.White's book are especially difficult because he made a number of mistakes 😟 11mo
86 likes1 stack add15 comments
blurb
ImperfectCJ
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image

I thought of the tagged book so many times during our 2-hour falconry experience yesterday. This local place has special certifications that allow them to offer interactive presentations to the public in a safe and legal way. I still kind of want to get into falconry, which I imagine would be rewarding, humbling, and very messy, but maybe I can just get my next job with a falconer. (This is me with a Harris's hawk.)

Tamra Gorgeous! 11mo
jlhammar Wow, so cool! I loved H is for Hawk and this one 11mo
batsy I just finished reading it! And loved it, so much to think about. Must be amazing to see one up close. 11mo
See All 7 Comments
ravenlee That‘s so cool! 11mo
ImperfectCJ @jlhammar I love Sy Montgomery's writing, but I haven't read that one yet...I'll have to pick it up sooner rather than later! 11mo
Hooked_on_books I did a falconry experience a few years ago. It was so cool! I‘ll never forget it. 11mo
ElizaMarie Such an amazing animal! 11mo
51 likes7 comments
quote
batsy
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image

Kind of lovely when book serendipity happens. Randomly picked H is for Hawk for the #TBRtarot this month, but as I see now it will feature T.H. White quite heavily because he wrote The Goshawk. It's something I didn't consciously register when I picked this up. Super illuminating to read this though, after reading The Once and Future King for the first time with the #OAFKingalong group!

Suet624 I‘d forgotten about that! 11mo
jlhammar Oh yes, I hadn‘t thought about that. Great timing! 11mo
batsy @Suet624 @jlhammar The insights are really interesting. Loving this so far. 11mo
69 likes3 comments
blurb
batsy
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image

Decided on my May pick for #TBRtarot and am very much looking forward to it! @CBee

CBee I‘ve heard good things about this one! 11mo
Billypar I thought this was fantastic - hope you like it as much as I did! 11mo
batsy @CBee Yes! 11mo
See All 12 Comments
batsy @Billypar So happy to hear that! Just managed the first few pages today and the writing is so good. 11mo
jlhammar Loved it. Hope you enjoy! 11mo
batsy @jlhammar Thank you! Glad to hear that you liked it. 11mo
Suet624 Enjoy! 11mo
batsy @Suet624 Thanks! 11mo
Fr3NcHtOaSt Love this book and the documentary on PBS was great as well 11mo
Goleemn Ohhh, a good book! Enjoy your pick! 11mo
batsy @Fr3NcHtOaSt I didn't know there was a documentary! Thank you, I will look it up. 11mo
batsy @Goleemn Thank you, I'm finding it quite brilliant! 11mo
70 likes12 comments
blurb
AvidReader25
post image

Guys, this section is LONG!!! I am suggesting we postpone our check-in until next Friday and go by the revised schedule below. Lancelot is one cranky dude and I still have a long way to go. 🤣 #OAFkingalong

April 28: The Ill-Made Knight - Favorite (or least fav) character so far.
May 5: The Candle in the Wind - Pick/So-So/Pan/Bail review

Lcsmcat I‘m ok with that. 12mo
RaeLovesToRead I've so far not managed to read much because I'm reading the Tawny Man trilogy too. When I get to it, I will go through all the posts with the hashtag as I read so I still feel like I'm joining in 🥰 (I'm not very good at being in more than one fantasy world at once.) 12mo
See All 15 Comments
AvidReader25 @RaeLovesToRead Catch up with us later! There‘s no hurry. 12mo
currentlyreadinginCO Def agree with the revised schedule. OAFK is getting a lot of side eyes on my nightstand ... like I'll get to you when I have a minute! 12mo
AvidReader25 @thereadingreference Total side eye! I lost some momentum after the dark turn in book 2. 12mo
BkClubCare LOL!! 🤣 maybe I can 🤔 still catch up ⬆️ to y‘all. #sigh 12mo
TheAromaofBooks Yes, that would work great! I divided each section by how many chapters I need to read per day to finish that section in a week, and this section is SEVEN chapters a day, which is wearing me down! 😂 12mo
MeganAnn @thereadingreference I keep doing that too! @AvidReader25 I lost a lot of momentum also and am having a harder time getting back into it. The extra time will definitely help. 12mo
rubyslippersreads Works for me. I haven‘t even started yet. 😏 12mo
batsy No problem at all. I'm a bad buddy reader in that I've read ahead. The Lancelot chapter is tough in parts but I also find this book so interesting—totally unlike the straightforward children's lit I mistakenly thought it was. 12mo
Vansa @batsy It wasn't written for children at all! 12mo
BarbaraJean Yes! Thank you! I‘ve gotten really behind this week. This helps to lighten my overloaded buddy-reading calendar 😆 12mo
AvidReader25 @BarbaraJean Same! The final section is much shorter, but this one is tough. 12mo
26 likes15 comments
review
Robotswithpersonality
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image
Mehso-so

Been trying to work out how I feel about this for the last day or so and I'm still conflicted.
Wretched dichotomy: the intimate window into appreciating a truly wild creature, so very different in nature from a human, but a terrible stolen privilege at that same time, the idea that for therapy in grief, you have a right to control another living being's behavior. 1/?

Robotswithpersonality I think primarily I suffered from a 'lack of synopsis reading', because I thought this would be a nature book about studying birds in the wild and how that helped the author heal from loss. It turned out to be a sad girl training a captive bird, whilst analysing an earlier account of a sadder man training a worse off bird, and as beautiful as the writing was, there's something ugly in that power dynamic. 2/? 13mo
Robotswithpersonality Bonus points for the sheer number of ways the same bird's colouration can be poetically described. 13mo
Robotswithpersonality Without the examination of T H White, his life and his book, would this memoir be half its size? Feels something like an academic analysis, bits relate directly to the growing relationship with the goshawk the author is training, but I don't know how much of White's life, beyond the tenuous connection of being lonely, really connects to the story the author is not quite telling about her own life, her own grief and, more fully, the journey with her own hawk. 4/5 13mo
See All 7 Comments
Robotswithpersonality Suffice to say, if this memoir had ended with her freeing the hawk, I'd feel differently. 13mo
CSeydel Great review 13mo
Robotswithpersonality ⚠️ Depression, sadism, internalized homophobia, animal cruelty, animal death 13mo
9 likes7 comments
quote
Robotswithpersonality
H is for Hawk | Helen Macdonald
post image

New word alert! Pretty sure it's just a fancy way to say 'hawkish'.
'Accipitrine: relating to birds of a family that includes most diurnal birds of prey other than falcons, New World vultures, and the osprey.'