Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#AuldLangSpine
review
Clare-Dragonfly
Primer | Thomas Krajewski, Jennifer Muro
post image
Mehso-so

Fun story. The characters felt pretty flat and, well, cartoonish—especially the villain. I thought everything came too easily to the main character. The idea of body paints that confer superpowers is very cool.

The art is incredibly fluid and vibrant. I felt like I was watching a really well-animated movie (Lilo and Stitch came to mind) instead of reading a book at times!

@Ellie_H #AuldLangSpine @monalyisha

TieDyeDude Good review! I think this character has a lot of potential, but it was definitely geared towards a young audience and focused more on the fun of becoming a hero than the challenges. 41m
Ellie_H Yay!!😁 I am so happy you liked some parts of the book!! (edited) now
15 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
TheKidUpstairs
Still Missing | Beth Gutcheon
post image
Pickpick

Whew, what an emotional experience! When 6 year old Alex Selky goes missing on his walk to school one day, police are baffled - no one just disappears without ANY trace. As time goes by and leads dwindle, we follow his mother Susan as her determination to find him alive never falters, despite the changing attitudes of those around her.

Cont'd in comments

#AuldLangSpine @CarolynM @monalyisha

TheKidUpstairs I particularly appreciated the depiction of what happens after a case leaves the news cycle (and this was in the 80s, such a drop would happen so much quicker these days), and it is left to those who care to try and keep a case and a memory alive, as other people move on with their lives, and disinformation muddies the waters.

cont'd
1h
TheKidUpstairs As it is from the 80s, you can expect some things to be a bit dated. I particularly felt it in the depictions of gay men. While it does strive to point out that there is no correlation between gay men and pedophilia, there is a certain scene that really clouds the line in a way that I did not feel was necessary, and did a disservice to the issue.

TW: child kidnapping, pedophilia, child physical and sexual abuse
1h
24 likes2 comments
review
JamieArc
Convenience Store Woman | Sayaka Murata
post image
Pickpick

I have been curious about this book for a while and am glad I had an impetus to finally read this. What a great little book exploring the life of a neurodivergent person. A lot of great ideas were explored including what it means to live your best life in the space of societal expectations. I was surprised to find myself often tense, wanting the best for Keiko. Another great one for #AuldLangSpine. I continue to read the list as promised!

Billypar I was also on edge, hoping things would work out for her! It's a great character study - Keiko feels like a real person, not some kind of case study like she might be in a lesser novel. now
25 likes1 comment
review
JamieArc
post image
Pickpick

I finished this at the end of January completing 5 books from my #AuldLangSpine list. This was as great as expected and really interesting to explore loneliness through different lenses with art that complimented the text. I hope Radtke keeps her graphic novels coming.

TheBookHippie He has the best books on his list!!!! 5h
JamieArc @TheBookHippie He really does! I‘ve enjoyed them because many were not even on my radar. 3h
25 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
TheKidUpstairs
Still Missing | Beth Gutcheon
post image

My ILLO on this one finally came in, so I'm returning to @CarolynM 's #AuldLangSpine list and preparing to be devastated.

@monalyisha

TrishB A good read 👍🏻 3d
Cathythoughts It‘s good , and yes , devastating ❤️ 3d
Tamra 😬 2d
TheKidUpstairs @TrishB @Cathythoughts @Tamra My daughter was begging me to walk to school on her own this morning. She's 5, and it's a 20 minute walk, so it would be a no anytime, but this morning it was a "heck no!" 2d
CarolynM It‘s tough but worth it. 2d
57 likes1 stack add5 comments
review
Larkken
post image
Pickpick

I liked this first Poirot novel enough that #christiescapers made my final #weeklyfavorite for January but I didn't love it. Red herrings everywhere, and so much talking it almost felt like a play, but an impressive 1st novel! My favorite reads this month are all from the #tob2025 longlist (one from the shortlist) so I'm happy to see it is still capable of introducing me to new authors to watch.
Lots of books in January! And a #bookspinbingo! 🔽

Larkken I finished both #bookspin and #doublespin books, one each #roll100 #readyourebooks and #auldlangspine picks, and our #LSFBC buddy read. I enjoyed both Redshirts and The Gilded Ones and plan to continue reading from @Lin3han list - in fact September House just came in from the library! In comparison February is off to a slow reading start, but I'm ok with that 😌 4d
Lin3han @Larkken Same here for your list! I‘m just waiting on tons of holds from Libby and hoopla. I loved September House much more than Gilded Ones so I hope you love it too!! 4d
TheAromaofBooks Yay!! Fantastic month!! 4d
Read4life Wonderful month!! 💙📚💙 3d
32 likes4 comments
review
Billypar
James: A Novel | Percival Everett
post image
Pickpick

#AuldLangSpine @JamieArc @monalyisha
I devoured most of this book on a plane ride from Newark to San Diego and wondered when I was passing over the Mississippi, where the action of this excellent novel plays out. I've been reading Huckleberry Finn at the same time, and what a complicated relationship there is between the two novels. I like how Everett didn't feel constrained to follow the original step by step, as a lot of retellings do. 👇

Billypar Instead, it seems like he wanted to explore James' and Huck's relationship in more depth. Those moments of Twain's novel are the most interesting, but also too few and far between. One that sticks out is when Huck tries to gaslight James into thinking he was imagining something. In Twain's novel, Jim is hurt that Huck would do that. But in Everett's novel, he's playing a role, and actually worries that he makes Huck feel too guilty. 👇 5d
Billypar It's the difference between a friendship and a paternal relationship. In Everett's version, James has to lie, not only out of self-preservation, but also because he knows how much Huck won't be able to understand about his situation. There's lots to appreciate about how this relationship develops, and throughout their story, Everett is very skilled at subtly shifting between comedic moments and the nightmarish realities of the time. 5d
monalyisha What an excellent review! 5d
See All 9 Comments
CarolynM Fabulous review. You‘ve actually made me consider reading it. 5d
BarbaraBB Fab review 5d
Anna40 Great review! 5d
JamieArc I read this review but apparently forgot to comment. It‘s been years since I‘ve read Huck Finn and decided not to revisit it while reading James. I‘m sure it would have made for much more interesting thinking if I had. You make a great point about Everett expertly shifting between comedic moments and horrific realities. That‘s how I felt about The Trees too. I‘ll get to Dr. No at some point soon though I now have high expectations of his books. 3h
Billypar @JamieArc I'd say that the comparison is interesting only for the first half of the novels. After that, the plots are totally different. And Huck Finn gets SO tedious. The dialogue goes on forever, with back and forths that are like unedited transcripts of real conversations (and ones full of racism and lame gags 😵‍💫). now
54 likes1 stack add9 comments
review
CSeydel
post image
Pickpick

Last one tonight. Another #auldlangspine - I listened to this one, and Griffin Dunne did an excellent job narrating this memoir of his extraordinary family. He begins with his mother‘s grandparents (I think) and touches on his father‘s difficult early life to set the stage for the family dynamics that infuse his life story, mostly his early years. Hilarious and wrenching. The climactic event is the 1983 trial of his sister Dominique‘s killer.

review
CSeydel
post image
Pickpick

Also #auldlangspine! I really lucked out with my partner this year. What I love about your list @CBee is the variety of styles you chose, and yet they are all so enjoyable. This was a fun, hilarious and cozy caper that was perfect for unwinding at the end of the evening. I loved that it had a truly all-ages cast of characters ranging in age from 8 months to 90 years. (Ok, he wasn‘t *actually* 90, but what happened was … )

CBee I‘m so happy that you‘re enjoying my list and the books I chose!! This one was so fun 😊😊 5d
48 likes1 comment
review
CSeydel
O Caledonia | Elspeth Barker
post image
Pickpick

Another #auldlangspine pick from @CBee

This was so unexpected and intense. I loved it and definitely see myself revisiting it in the future. A haunting story of an odd little family in post-WWII Scotland, and a bright and sensitive young girl who is deeply unconventional and frequently misunderstood. Richly drawn and evocative portrait of a unique time and place. The writing is spare yet poetic. 4.5⭐️

CBee Spare yet poetic - perfect description 👏🏻 5d
54 likes2 stack adds1 comment