Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Thunderclap
Thunderclap: A Memoir of Art and Life and Sudden Death | Laura Cumming
12 posts | 6 read | 1 reading | 7 to read
New York Times bestselling author and art critic Laura Cumming reveals the fascinating, little-known story of the Thunderclapthe massive explosion at a gunpowder store in Holland that killed Carel Fabritius, renowned painter of The Goldfinch and nearly killed Johannes Vermeer, painter of Girl with a Pearl Earringtwo of the greatest artists of the 17th century. As a brilliant art critic and historian, Laura Cumming has explored the importance of art in life and can give us a perspective on the time and place in which the artist worked. Now, through the lens of one dramatic event in 17th century Holland, Cumming illuminates one of the most celebrated periods in art history. In 1654, an enormous explosion at a gunpowder store devasted the city of Delft, killing hundreds of people and injuring thousands more. Among those killed was the extraordinary painter Carel Fabritius, renowned for his paintings The Goldfinch and his haunting masterpiece A View of Delft, which depicts the very streets through which the victims would be carried to their graves. Fabritiuss contemporary and rival Vermeer, painter of the iconic portrait Girl with a Pearl Earring, narrowly escaped death. Framing the story around Fabritiuss life, Cumming deftly weaves a sequence of observations about paintings and how they relate to everyday life. Like Dutch art itself, the story gradually links country, city, town, street, house, interiorall the way to the bird on its perch, the blue and white tile, the smallest seed in a loaf of bread. The impact of a painting and how it can enter our thoughts, influence our views, and understanding of the world is the heart of this book and Cumming has brought her unique eye to her most compelling subject yet. Featuring beautiful full-color images of Dutch paintings throughout, this is a stunningly rich book about one of the most vibrant periods in European art and life.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
ChaoticMissAdventures
post image
Pickpick

Good but not great. I can both see why this made the women's prize long list and why it didn't make the short list. Similar to Wifedom I thought there was too much of the author in this book. The time she is choosing to talk about is fascinating and it didn't need personal story embellishments. I feel like authors do this when they cannot find enough source material. The book itself is gorgeous, and I did learn a lot so it is still a pick!

ChaoticMissAdventures I am glad the WP had this listed, I never would have found it on my own and it is a great primer since I plan this year to read 4d
35 likes1 comment
quote
ChaoticMissAdventures
post image

"I cannot get enough Dutch art. You can turn to this other world - and it is a picture world as no other, a whole society visualized through time and place, seasons and generations, moment by moment - and live inside it in your thoughts."

The painting that starts the book.

Becker I‘m also reading this right now and really enjoying the art discussions. 5d
AnneCecilie I loved this too, and particularly how Dutch art focuses on the everyday 5d
21 likes2 comments
quote
ChaoticMissAdventures
post image

"We see pictures in time and place. We cannot see them otherwise. They are fragments of our lives, moments of existence that may be as unremarkable as rain or as startling as a clap of thunder."

blurb
jenniferw88
post image
review
jenniferw88
post image
Pickpick
57 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
AnneCecilie
post image
Pickpick

A book of twos; one part is about the The Golden Age of Dutch art focusing mainly on Delft. And I‘ve been to Delft and I love art so I loved this part. Who knew Dutch Art where so available to its citizens and not something for just the royals and nobility? The other part is about her and her parents. Her father was an artist. I found this part interesting. I loved how she used her own experiences to explain the Dutch artists.

blurb
Leniverse
post image

Had to google this painting as it isn't printed in the book, and the description fascinated me. Memorial portrait made by siblings Gerard and Gesina Ter Borch after the death of their youngest brother, Moses who fell in battle against the English. Look at that hair! The pose! The pieces of his armour! The time pieces! The snake! The random skull and puppy and huge conch shell. ❤️💔

tpixie Amazing. I love to google as I read- even though it slows me down!!! 3w
37 likes1 comment
quote
AnneCecilie
post image

This was the masterpiece that drew Marcel Proust out of his cork-lined room in Paris for the last time. He had seen it once before, in a visit to The Hague in 1902. It was to him ‘the most beautiful painting in the world‘. Almost twenty years later, suffering from lung disease, he made a shorter but more arduous pilgrimage from his apartment in boulevard Malesherbes, near the Madeleine, across four streets to the Jeu de Paume,

AnneCecilie where it was appearing on its travels in 1921. (Writing about Vermeer‘s View of Delft, pictured) 1mo
charl08 Beautiful painting. 1mo
batsy That's lovely. 1mo
55 likes3 comments
blurb
jlhammar
post image

The spoils of today‘s bookshop visit!

squirrelbrain Ooh, good haul! ❤️ 1mo
Tamra 👏🏾👏🏾 1mo
batsy Nice! 1mo
sarahbarnes Reading Enter Ghost right now. It‘s very good. 1mo
71 likes4 comments
review
Hooked_on_books
post image
Pickpick

This is a book that shouldn‘t work. It meanders all over the place and trying to write an outline for it would be an exercise in futility. Yet, somehow, these musings on (mainly) Dutch art, primarily that of Carel Fabritius, the author‘s painter father, artists lives and her own life comes together as a pretty magical read. The illustrations are great, but there was still plenty I was googling. Completely fascinating.

Hooked_on_books Helen, I‘m so glad you mentioned the format in your review. I‘m really glad I ended up with the print and not audio. I actually think the audio would work really well if one was sitting and looking at the images while listening, but I‘m always doing other stuff while listening to audiobooks and I would have missed out. @squirrelbrain 1mo
squirrelbrain I‘m glad you went with print! I was doing other stuff too whilst listening (mainly driving so definitely couldn‘t look stuff up! 😬). I‘m getting the digital print copy from BorrowBox in about 2 weeks and looking forward to seeing the pictures. 1mo
55 likes2 stack adds2 comments
review
youneverarrived
post image
Pickpick

This was beautifully told. I loved listening to the author tell of Dutch paintings & artists, Fabritius & her father‘s paintings - you can tell it‘s something she‘s knowledgeable & passionate about. I listened on Spotify which came with a pdf of all the paintings she discusses but I always listen when I‘m on the go so couldn‘t keep track of which paintings she was discussing. As much as I liked the audio I‘d recommend going print or mix the two.

Leniverse This is waiting for me at the library, so I guess it will be my next NF. The shortlist has reshuffled all my plans 😅 1mo
BarbaraBB This sounds good. 1mo
See All 8 Comments
squirrelbrain I wished I‘d done print too. In fact I‘m on the BorrowBox waiting list for it. 1mo
youneverarrived @Leniverse I know what you mean 😆 I‘m hoping this one I‘ve got reserved will be available soon as it‘s the one I‘m most interested in reading 1mo
youneverarrived @BarbaraBB it was a great read 👍 1mo
youneverarrived @squirrelbrain I think seeing the paintings whilst reading would have added to it. It looks like a gorgeous book. 1mo
Leniverse @youneverarrived Doppelganger is the only one I've read so far, and I started that before the longlist was even announced 🤪 Non-fiction takes me so long. And Doppelganger was heavy going at times. But it was also really interesting and extremely relevant, so well worth the effort. 1mo
53 likes1 stack add8 comments
review
squirrelbrain
post image
Pickpick

This #womensprize for NF long-lister is still a pick, but I chose the wrong format (audio).The author describes so many paintings and I wanted to see them - not the best idea when you listen whilst driving, as I mostly do. 😬

Even when I was at home, as all of the artists are Dutch, I couldn‘t find many of them as I didn‘t know how to spell their names. I‘ve reserved the (digital) print copy so I can re-read but it‘s not available until ⬇️

squirrelbrain ….the end of April. I also felt that the book was more weighted towards Fabritius and Dutch art whereas there should have been more about her father. 2mo
rockpools Ohhh, interesting. I actually just started this last night on ebook, and I‘m surprised how much I‘m loving it. (C17th Dutch Art is NOT one of my pet subjects!) But yes, you definitely need the pictures. I‘m also going in not having read anything else by her, so I think my lack of expectations is maybe a help. 2mo
squirrelbrain @rockpools - I didn‘t notice so much at the start, but she introduces more and more artists as she goes along, and not well-known ones either. I love her narration though, so maybe would have also felt like I was missing out if I‘d done print. I listened to On Chapel Sands too - I think you‘d really like it. 2mo
See All 14 Comments
rockpools @squirrelbrain 👍I‘ve wishlisted that on audio, for later. Thanks for the recommendation. I think I mentally filed it as True Crime when it came out, so ignored all the glowing reviews. Will definitely take a listen. 2mo
BarbaraBB Interesting. Some 17th century Dutch painters were real masters. 2mo
ChaoticMissAdventures This is so good to know, thanks! Going to make sure I have the physical book on hold. 2mo
Hooked_on_books Oh, that‘s good to know. I have access to the audio through Everand, but clearly that‘s not the way I should go. 2mo
youneverarrived As much as I‘m enjoying the audio I agree it would be better in print (I saw the hardback in a bookshop I was in yesterday and had a quick look through 😍). 2mo
squirrelbrain Ooh, did it have pictures? @youneverarrived 2mo
youneverarrived It did, full page pictures of the paintings - it would be a beautiful book to own 😍 2mo
squirrelbrain Ohhhhh…I don‘t need any more books…I don‘t need any more books. Just tagging you both in @ChaoticMissAdventures @Hooked_on_books - sounds like you definitely need a ‘real‘ book with this one. Thanks Katie! @youneverarrived 2mo
ChaoticMissAdventures @squirrelbrain my library has a copy! There is a wait-list, but I think I will take the time to wait on it. I am trying to be so much better this year about not buying things unless I read and loved them but it is so hard with the Women's Prize! 2mo
Hooked_on_books I‘ve already put the print book on hold at my library. 😬 I‘m slowly succumbing to reading this list soon rather than waiting! 2mo
squirrelbrain @ChaoticMissAdventures @Hooked_on_books - I‘ve also put the print book on hold at the library…. 2mo
71 likes1 stack add14 comments