Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#wilderness
review
Doppoetry
Into the Wild | Jon Krakauer
post image
Pickpick

I'm not really sure what to think of all of this, overall, but I do believe that if this young man had listened to advice, taken precautions, and been better prepared, he would have been able to survive. I think we share a lot of personality traits and opinions, but at the same time, for being so academically smart, he made some foolhardy choices that led to his demise.

Texreader I love Krakauer‘s writing. He‘s so good. And your review is spot on. 2d
Doppoetry @Texreader Thank you! Krakauer really put things into a neutral perspective and covered it from all sides. Overall, I do think of this as a tragedy. 2d
Texreader @Doppoetry It really was a tragedy. And that‘s why I think Krakauer is so good. He can tell a compelling and interesting story without injecting himself. 2d
8 likes4 comments
blurb
Blueberry
Wilderness Days | Sigurd F. Olson
post image

Up next. I hope it's a feel good book.

Tamra I just heard an MPR story that referenced Sigurd Olson. 😁 3d
Blueberry @Tamra Interesting. I'll try to look it up. 3d
Tamra It was in reference to MN nature observer writer Helen Hoover. New NF is out about Helen. https://northshorejournal.co/news/author-david-hakensen-on-the-life-of-helen-hoo... 3d
41 likes3 comments
review
Robotswithpersonality
post image
Pickpick

A bit more of a guide than a memoir, you get a more straightforward introduction to Smith's early years, a brief account of his journeys in the wilderness, primarily in Canada (felt ridiculously proud of his admiring descriptions of BC), prior to settling in one wood. But the story of his time at Loch Treig is divided more along the lines of what is essential to think about/know/do if you contemplate this lifestyle, especially in the Scottish 1/?

Robotswithpersonality 2/? Scottish Highlands. The way of the hermit, indeed.
I love that what shines through clearest in all of his advice and reminiscences is strongly valuing kindness, generosity, and conservation. Much as he may have found more peace without the crush of an urban population, he is quick to acknowledge all those people who have helped him along his way.
4d
Robotswithpersonality 3/? That gratitude extends to the land he's lived on, it's beauty and bounty, and a consistent, conscientious, somewhat mournful focus on the need to tread lightly, the ways the local climate, ecosystem has changed linked to an understanding of this being a microcosm of the larger environmental concerns of today.
4d
Robotswithpersonality 4/? There's a bit of 'old man yells at cloud' in his perspective, unable to reconcile the idea that people might enjoy a city life or a desk job, and as passionate as he is in championing nature, I do wish he seemed more optimistic about rewilding efforts in the U.K. Especially as you see him move from a ghillie aiding in deer stalking (aka helping people hunt deer on the estate because indigenous predators have been wiped out, 4d
See All 9 Comments
Robotswithpersonality 5/? and population control of deer is necessary to maintain the health of the local ecosystem) to someone who is relieved his advancing age removes him from those staff who have to kill the animals - though he laments that he can no longer fish in the loch, as it is now experiencing it's own population concerns.
4d
Robotswithpersonality 6/? There are sections of the book that I wish had gone into more detail, where we might have gained a bit more of his inner thoughts/life than a description of events, but the book at this size does make better odds that more people will pick it up. I do also wonder, now that I know there was a documentary, The Hermit of Treig, about this man that pre-dates, indeed partially inspired this book, if that might cover his life in a different way. 4d
Robotswithpersonality 7/? Overall, I think you can take inspiration from the way he's lived his life, without, as he himself states, going as far as he did. He does acknowledge when his life choices were risky, but urges and exemplifies caution a great deal more. Nevertheless, his scale of toughness means the average reader will probably be a little stunned at what he occasionally shrugs off. 4d
Robotswithpersonality 8/? There is humour and humility and resilience. A good read physically or on audio.
Definitely a collaborative effort, as Smith had Millard's assistance in writing the book, and Dean Williamson narrates the audiobook. Unsure of the origins of the accent, but it works to tell this story. I should mention, there are differences between physical book and audio, I assume the audio is based off the UK written version, with a fair amount of local
4d
Robotswithpersonality 9/? parlance thrown in, and it's obvious the written version I've got has been revised to substitute more North American synonyms. I found the foreign slang utterly charming, while also being grateful for a reference with more familiar terms to translate. ☺️ Can highly recommend the tandem reading experience for my fellow North American readers.
4d
Robotswithpersonality 10/10 ⚠️Loss of parents, discussion of depression, animal death, mention of injury, suicide, cancer diagnosis and treatment 4d
13 likes9 comments
quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

💅🏼 He's judging us. 😅

quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

“You shouldn't feel self-conscious about saying kind words to anything.“ 🥰🌹

quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

😌🍂❄️

Texreader ♥️ 🍁 🍂 4d
9 likes1 comment
quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

...always new growth...

quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

💚

quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

Already in love with the writing.

review
Suelizbeth
Into the Wild | Jon Krakauer
post image
Pickpick

I sympathize with Chris McCandless‘ family over his loss, but also understand how he hurt them with his unstinting moral code. It seemed to be more than youthful hubris. A deliberate unwillingness to communicate with loved ones caused them all so much hurt. If he had come out of the Alaska wilderness alive, one hopes that he would have learned enough from the experience of extreme isolation to resolve his familial differences. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️