Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#LibertariansOnThePrairie
review
GingerAntics
post image
Pickpick

The choice to make this a pick is probably going to shock some people, but that‘s okay.

I‘ve heard people say “if you love the Little House books, don‘t read this book.” I don‘t think it matters. Either you‘re open to the possibility that those books are actually works of fiction, or you‘re not. Either you‘re open to the possibility that Laura doesn‘t always believe in doing the right thing, or you‘re not. 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻

GingerAntics If you‘re not, this won‘t change you‘re mind. It will just be a waste of your time. If you are, you‘re in for a wild ride. Neither Laura nor Rose are particularly likeable women. Be prepared for the “always do the right thing” family to commit tax fraud and recommend tax evasion. Quite frankly, the word that comes most readily to mind when thinking of these women is: vile. 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻 4y
GingerAntics The views expressed by Rose and Laura aren‘t even consistent within themselves. Everyone just needs to work hard in order to be successful is followed by some people are just too low born to have any hope of bettering themselves, no matter how hard they work. This is followed by, those who are not successful are getting what they deserve. 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻 (edited) 4y
GingerAntics So according to the Ingles Wilder/Wilder Lane logic, hard work makes everyone successful, unless you‘re too low born, then there is no helping you, but it‘s your fault you were low born. Their entire world view is based on a misunderstanding (that still exists today) of the Horatio Alger Myth. Rose has pointed out the flaw in her own thinking and hasn‘t even realised it. 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻 4y
See All 11 Comments
GingerAntics Not everyone can pull themselves up by their boot straps because not everyone is born with boots. Unlike Horatio Alger‘s characters, not everyone born without boots has someone come along and hand them boots. 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻 4y
GingerAntics I have only one complaint about the actual book itself (Woodside‘s writing). The book argues that Rose was a self made intellectual. She implies on at least a few occasions that Rose Wilder Lane was a classic autodidact. So why does Woodside reduce her to a number on the scale/the size of her waistline when she could have just said Rose had noticeably aged? 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻 4y
GingerAntics Woodside has photos in the back. People could have figured it out for themselves. Instead, she called her “white-haired” and “overweight.” So even thought Woodside is arguing that this woman is brilliant and made herself that way with no outside help, she‘s still only as valuable as her weight. Why does her appearance make any difference? It makes no sense. #ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon (edited) 4y
Kelly_the_Bookish_Sidekick This isn't a book I would read but it's been fun reading the quotes you highlighted and your thoughts. 4y
GingerAntics @Kelly_the_Bookish_Sidekick you and me both. If it hadn‘t been on sale ($2), another litten hadn‘t started a group read of it, and there wasn‘t a moment I was apparently feeling a bit crazy, I wouldn‘t have read it either. Not that you mention it, I have no idea how on Earth I ended up reading this book. How did I get here? What day is this? (Seriously thought it was Sunday when I woke up this morning.) 🤣😂🤣 4y
Bette 😳 wow. 😯 Having grown up with those books your review is eye opening. Thanks for sharing. 4y
GingerAntics @Bette luckily I never could get into the books, but I was obsessed with the show. At first, I was able to view the show as more of a Michael Landon creation and very separate from the books, because really it is, but I‘m starting to see the subtle messaging in the show, too. It‘s hard to realise something you loved as a child, something you idolised, would label you “low born” and that there was no use in someone like me trying. 4y
GingerAntics @Bette good thing I didn‘t listen to the RL people in my childhood who said those things, so knowing one of my favourite shows was also saying it probably would have just made me not like the show. Still, that madness shouldn‘t be in a children‘s show. Period. 4y
15 likes11 comments
quote
GingerAntics
post image

Don‘t tell the guy writing the book on “The Faith of Laura Ingles Wilder.” He‘ll be heartbroken and so will his wife. (She reads to him while he‘s driving and he reads to her while she‘s doing chores.)
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

I would LOVE to talk to these folks, because I have never heard of them. I would love to hear their thoughts on this, especially since most “progressive, left-wing” readers and parents are moving to other, similar books due to the racism and prejudice in this series.
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

I can‘t speak for all of them, but the ones I know love them because they uphold tradition gender roles.
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

The answer is, she couldn‘t, unless there are some “lost” or “hidden” works of fiction by LIW that no one knows about, even now. Maybe Rose burned those when she died. #sarcasm
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

Her beliefs laid out for children and her beliefs laid out for adults. How exciting. #sarcasm
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

What a shock. They didn‘t jus you‘ll themselves up by their boot straps (and wouldn‘t have during the Great Depression if the books hadn‘t sold).
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

Do they? Do they really? The backlash at the mere suggestion that Laura had any help writing them proves most readers do NOT understand they are reading myth, especially today when even suggesting a beloved belief or historical figure is shrouded in mythology gets you labelled a “snowflake” and “hater of history.”
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

Again, wrong on the historical points. This was not the case for black or brown people in America. Then again, they seemed fine with taking Indian land and outraged when they were told land wasn‘t theirs so they had to leave. 🙄 White privilege on display again, here. #factsmatter #historymatters #whyhistorymatters #ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

quote
GingerAntics
post image

This is my FIRST complaint about the book itself. It‘s well written. It‘s well researched. Why does her weight matter to anything? This could have been summed up much more concisely as “The woman who returned had aged significantly and become paranoid.” No judgement based on looks or weight. Good lord, what year was this book written in?
#ChristineWoodside #LibertariansOnThePrairie #WomenAlsoKnowHistory #LauraRoseReadathon

Jeannineth Totally agree. She sounds like she‘s older, wiser, and opinionated. 4y
GingerAntics @Jeannineth I think she was always rather opinionated. 4y
Kelly_the_Bookish_Sidekick I do think the overweight comment paints a fuller picture. It's a judgy comment, but aging doesn't always equal weight gain, so I see it as a change in the physical. 4y
GingerAntics @Kelly_the_Bookish_Sidekick not always but usually, especially in that time frame. She still came from the age of women who bragged about having to take out their dresses after getting married. Laura certainly would have. It just seems unnecessary. For a book discussing her mind/intellect, her writing, and her politics, it‘s just unnecessary in my opinion, especially since this book is written by a woman. 4y
8 likes4 comments