Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Who Goes There
Who Goes There | John W. Campbell
4 posts | 3 read | 1 to read
A group of scientists. An object buried under the ice. A terrifying fight for survival. When a group of scientific researchers, isolated in Antarctica, stumble across an alien spaceship buried in the ice it seems like an incredible opportunity. The alien pilot can just be seen - a shadowy figure frozen just a short depth into the ice. It looks as though he survived the crash only to be flash-frozen on the Antarctic plateau. The team fight the frozen conditions to free the ship from the ice - with disastrous consequences - and rescue the alien. As they transport the corpse, one of their greatest finds, out on the ice back to their camp, several scientists begin to experience extraordinary, vivid and unsettling dreams. They're dismissed as the product of stress and the harsh conditions ... but the nightmare is only beginning.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Twainy
Who Goes There | John W. Campbell
post image
Pickpick

I loved this. A super short story, the basis of John Carpenter‘s The Thing! A movie that still haunts me. It‘s nice to see a movie‘s origin story 😉

And. I met my GoodReads challenge for 2024 😆

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Pageturner1 didn‘t we just start 2024? WOW 🤩 great job 👏 2mo
BookmarkTavern Woohoo! 🎉 2mo
Twainy @Pageturner1 @BookmarkTavern thank you. It‘s funny because I guiltily use the GR challenge to track the books I read … I think a challenge would stress me out & I‘d read less. 🤷🏼‍♀️ This year my challenge is to DNF a book or two 😁 & catch up on some of my reviews. Enjoy reading 🎉 2mo
30 likes3 comments
review
Bookwomble
Who Goes There | John W. Campbell
post image
Pickpick

2:2 Campbell was a racist who, as a sci fi magazine editor, turned down a Samuel R. Delany story due to the Black protagonist. I'm reminded of the Star Trek DS9 episodes in which Captain Sisko thinks he's a 1950s sci fi writer whose editor won't print his "Deep Space 9" story unless he removes the unacceptably Black station commander.
His prejudice was condemned by Asimov, and Philip K. Dick considered him a Nazi. His work reads differently now.

review
Bookwomble
Who Goes There | John W. Campbell
post image
Pickpick

1:2 The stories in this collection are pretty solid, from the sci-fi horror of the title story and the currently topical horror of Dead Knowledge, through the maguffin-based gadget stories, to the far-future tales about the Heat Death of the universe. The tone runs from an optimistically plucky "Good Ole American Grit Will Overcome", to a decidedly pessimistic "What's the Point?", even if that end is untold billions of years in the future. 4?

review
Bookwomble
Who Goes There | John W. Campbell
post image
Pickpick

This was the 1000th book on my tbr mountain, but temporarily occupies the limbo place between "to read" and "read" that is "currently reading".
The title story is famously the inspiration for the films "The Thing from Another World" & "The Thing". Campbell's novella is full of claustrophobic paranoia & sci-fi horror.
There's an albatross which could have carried some nice literary symbolism, but Campbell avoided that, for some reason: too obvious?