Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Genetic Lottery
The Genetic Lottery: Why DNA Matters for Social Equality | Kathryn Paige Harden
4 posts | 2 read | 1 to read
A provocative and timely case for how the science of genetics can help create a more just and equal society In recent years, scientists like Kathryn Paige Harden have shown that DNA makes us different, in our personalities and in our health—and in ways that matter for educational and economic success in our current society. In The Genetic Lottery, Harden introduces readers to the latest genetic science, dismantling dangerous ideas about racial superiority and challenging us to grapple with what equality really means in a world where people are born different. Weaving together personal stories with scientific evidence, Harden shows why our refusal to recognize the power of DNA perpetuates the myth of meritocracy, and argues that we must acknowledge the role of genetic luck if we are ever to create a fair society. Reclaiming genetic science from the legacy of eugenics, this groundbreaking book offers a bold new vision of society where everyone thrives, regardless of how one fares in the genetic lottery.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
shanaqui
Panpan

This book means very well, but a) it actually explains things very badly, despite trying very hard, and b) fails to make a good case for taking DNA into account in trying to create a more equal society.

blurb
shanaqui

I am completely glazing over with this book. We're 100 pages in, and she's overcomplicatedly explained genome-wide association studies via an analogy that takes more time to lay out than it does to just explain GWAS on its own terms, and otherwise she's mostly just said: intelligence is influenced by genetics, the differences between individuals can be large, the differences between ancestral groups are likely not due to variations in the same...

shanaqui ...genes, so we shouldn't compare ancestral groups to one another, “race“ =/= ancestry, and that she's going to show that we should use all this understanding to help people who don't have genes for educational attainment reach the same standards.

We could've got to this point faster.

I've also endured reading a review of this book which drips racism from every pore, and I feel dirty.
1w
shanaqui Oh, it's also super US-centric. 1w
Faranae When I looked it up on Wikipedia, the negative reviews from scholars were basically all like “the road to hell is paved with good intentions“ about it. 1w
shanaqui @Faranae That sounds about right. 1w
SamAnne Well, ick. Double ick.. and sorry. 1w
11 likes5 comments
blurb
shanaqui

This one is gonna have to be a slow read for me, because I can feel myself glazing over at times, but I do really want to read it.

To be clear: the author fully believes that intelligence is a heritable trait (along with perhaps other stuff related to success), and that we should take it into account in order to make society equitable (NOT that some people are more deserving than others as a result).