50 contemporary poets respond to a poem of their choice from the past: great idea! As with all anthologies, there are hits and misses. I regret to conclude that in many cases the original poem was clearly the stronger of the two and, for me, the smirking smart-arse school of poetry was over-represented. Brought to mind the Salvator Rosa portrait whose Latin motto loosely translates as "either say something better than silence or shut the hell up."