Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Weak Strongman
Weak Strongman: The Limits of Power in Putin's Russia | Timothy Frye
2 posts | 1 read | 1 to read
Looking beyond Putin to understand how today's Russia actually works Media and public discussion tends to understand Russian politics as a direct reflection of Vladimir Putin's seeming omnipotence or Russia's unique history and culture. Yet Russia is remarkably similar to other autocracies—and recognizing this illuminates the inherent limits to Putin's power. Weak Strongman challenges the conventional wisdom about Putin's Russia, highlighting the difficult trade-offs that confront the Kremlin on issues ranging from election fraud and repression to propaganda and foreign policy. Drawing on three decades of his own on-the-ground experience and research as well as insights from a new generation of social scientists that have received little attention outside academia, Timothy Frye reveals how much we overlook about today's Russia when we focus solely on Putin or Russian exceptionalism. Frye brings a new understanding to a host of crucial questions: How popular is Putin? Is Russian propaganda effective? Why are relations with the West so fraught? Can Russian cyber warriors really swing foreign elections? In answering these and other questions, Frye offers a highly accessible reassessment of Russian politics that highlights the challenges of governing Russia and the nature of modern autocracy. Rich in personal anecdotes and cutting-edge social science, Weak Strongman offers the best evidence available about how Russia actually works.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Sophronisba
post image
Pickpick

This book is academic but accessible -- the writing won't wow you but it's not filled with jargon. The most useful takeaway: although it is tempting to think of Russia as either historically addicted to autocracy or in thrall to the strong personality of Vladimir Putin, the reality on the ground is more complicated than that. Putin is more constrained than you might imagine, and the Russian present is affected by but not determined by its past.

Sophronisba I am not sure that the author's “weak strongman“ hypothesis holds up that well in light of Russia's recent invasion of Ukraine. It certainly does not seem that Putin is being particularly constrained by either the people of Russia as a whole or the oligarchs. On the other hand, until the current crisis is over, we won't really know the truth of what is going on -- and very possibly not even then. 2y
10 likes1 comment
quote
Sophronisba
post image

I think of a French language teacher I met in Uzbekistan in 1988. She was a Francophile to her core, which was all the more remarkable in that she had never been to France. Even more depressing, she had little hope of ever seeing the City of Lights. In her living room, she had a three-dimensional map of Paris that she knew as well as the streets of her native Taskhent.

Sophronisba I desperately want to know if this woman ever got to see Paris. 2y
11 likes1 stack add1 comment