
This is a fictionalised account of when Penelope Fitzgerald, with her 6 year old son, travelled to Mexico in 1952 at the whim of two elderly sisters who supposedly have an inheritance to bestow.
I found this pedestrian - nothing much happened. It also felt very muddled, with many loose ends, cul-de-sacs and contradictions. (And not in a ‘work it out for yourself‘ way, more a bad editing way)
By far the most annoying thing, though, was ⬇️
squirrelbrain …the audio. DON‘T listen to this, unless you like to listen to someone doing an impression of a squeaky, precocious 6 year old. I nearly switched off at the start and wished I had done! Then, there was a Spanish-speaking character, who I presume was meant to be gay, as he was even higher-pitched and with a lisp as well. 🙄 😠 (edited) 3d
TheKidUpstairs Good to know. I was intrigued by the "novel about Penelope Fitzgerald" part, because I love her, but the rest of the description didn't really do much for me. Sounds like I can comfortably skip this one. And, ugh, I hate when narrators push too hard to do "voices", especially for children. 3d
Bookwormjillk Good to know about the audio. Thanks for the warning. 3d
See All 14 Comments
Aims42 Ugh, I hate bad audiobook narrators 😒 They 100% make or break it for me too. And why do they give kids squeaky voices?? It‘s so unrealistic and totally takes me out of the experience. Sorry, didn‘t realize how mad this makes me until just now 🤣 3d
ChaoticMissAdventures This sounds like a skip! Thanks for taking one for the team 😂 3d
Lesliereadsalot Thanks for including me and saving me lots of hours! 3d
Hooked_on_books Oh dear! My library only has the ebook and clearly that‘s a good thing! Those audio choices would make me crazy. 3d
sarahbarnes Wow, thanks for the heads up on this one. I was curious about it given the Penelope Fitzgerald connection, but it sounds like one to skip. Or at least on audio. 3d
Deblovestoread Put a big X on my list. Thanks for doing the work ❤️ 3d
squirrelbrain I‘m worried now that I‘m an outlier, as I‘ve just checked the GR reviews and they‘re not that bad! 😬 Maybe someone else *should* read it (Holly?!) to get another view - just not the audio! 😝 @TheKidUpstairs @Bookwormjillk @ChaoticMissAdventures @Lesliereadsalot @Hooked_on_books @sarahbarnes @Deblovestoread 2d
squirrelbrain @Aims42 - there were a lot of accents in this one too. Spanish / Mexican of course but also Irish and Scottish, which weren‘t too bad. A short burst of the Welsh accent sounded Indian to me! 😬 2d
Hooked_on_books Oh, I‘ll be giving it a try! I won‘t be getting it for another month or so based on the holds info, but it will happen! 2d
Chelsea.Poole Uh oh. I would only listen to this one if I do it at all so it sounds like I should skip. It wasn‘t that appealing to me anyway, I must say. 2d
BarbaraBB You‘re making it easy for me to take a pass on this one! 2d
58 likes14 comments












