Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Land of the Living
Land of the Living | Georgina Harding
1 post | 1 read | 1 to read
A profound masterpiece on war, loss and survival, rendered in prose of rhythmic precision, subtlety and exceptional sensitivity, by the Orange Prize-shortlisted author of Painter of Silence 'Arresting and brutal - the finely tuned work of a writer exceptionally at ease with her craft and a testament to the power and poetry of clean and disciplined prose' Sadie Jones, Guardian Charlie 's experiences at the Battle of Kohima and the months he spent lost in the remote jungles of Assam during the Second World War are now history. Home and settled on a farm in Norfolk and newly married to Claire, he is one of the lucky survivors. Starting a family and working the land seem the best things a man can be doing. But a chasm exists between them. Memories flood Charlie 's mind; at night, on rain-slicked roads and misty mornings in the fields, the past can feel more real than the present. What should be said and what left unsaid' Is it possible to find connection and forge a new life in the wake of unfathomable horror' A beautifully conceived, deftly controlled and delicately wrought meditation on the isolating impact of war and the inescapable reach of the past, Georgina Harding 's haunting and lyrical novel questions the very nature of survival, and what it is that the living owe the dead.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
readingjedi
Land of the Living | Georgina Harding
post image
Panpan

I didn't enjoy this book for several reasons but I'm going to pick on one. The lack of speech marks. Just ... why? What does it actually bring to the table? To me it's a pointless stylistic affectation that only serves to confuse and alienate the reader but it seems it's increasingly fashionable. All other punctuation is present & correct. In this book there was also no indication of who was speaking either. Grinds my gears!!!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬

TheShaggyShepherd That sounds terrible. I‘ve read a couple ARCs lately where the speech punctuation was off a bit and that was already irritating enough. 5y
paulfrankspencer Don't read Cormac McCarthy. He's so good, but that'll drive you nuts. 5y
readingjedi @paulfrankspencer I've read The Road and it didn't bother me in that as it was clear what was speech & who was speaking. And I got the point of the omission - immediacy, realism etc. But in lesser hands it's just confusing and, yes, it drives me nuts 🤣 5y
See All 7 Comments
paulfrankspencer @readingjedi he is the master, though I found it confusing in some books sometimes, like his border series (which is soooooo good). Others should wade in warily. 5y
TheAromaofBooks I'm like you - the question is, what does omitting quotation marks actually accomplish?? I just don't get it. 5y
AlaMich I completely agree! Stop being fancy for fancy‘s sake and just write a good book! *steps down off soapbox* 5y
jillrhudy I absolutely HATE when they leave out the quotation marks. 5y
81 likes7 comments